In sport studies, process goals improve performance most and outcome goals least, and combining goal types appears to work better than relying on an outcome goal alone
Interpretation
A meta-analysis of 27 sport studies found process goals d = 1.36, performance goals d = 0.44 and outcome goals d = 0.09, with process goals also raising self-efficacy (Williamson 2024). An earlier meta-analysis of 36 studies found goal setting improved performance by 0.34 SD, most with moderate, absolute and combined short- and long-term goals (Kyllo 1995). Small trials support process goals in 37 club golfers (Kingston 1997) and multiple-goal strategies in 40 participants on a soccer task (Filby 1999). An applied review of 27 athlete interventions found small samples and mixed support for goal-setting theory (Jeong 2023). Monitoring progress promoted goal attainment (d = 0.40) across 138 mostly non-sport trials (Harkin 2016). Graded limited: consistent direction, but mostly small studies of short skill tasks, no endurance or triathlon trials and no sex-specific results.
Practical implication
Stack goals: one outcome goal for the season, moderate performance goals per block, and two or three concrete process goals for each key session and race leg, reviewed weekly in a log. Extrapolated from skill sports and general psychology; effect sizes will not transfer directly to long endurance races, and no goal should override warning signs or illness.
Sources
6 sources, independently verified.
27 sport studies (from 17,841 records). Performance effects: process goals d = 1.36, performance goals d = 0.44, outcome goals d = 0.09; specific (d = 0.37) and non-specific goals (d = 0.72) not significantly different; process goals raised self-efficacy (d = 1.11); self-regulation-theory studies d = 1.53 (k = 5). Psychological outcomes rarely poolable. Mostly short, skill-based tasks. Published online 2022, print 2024.
Meta-analysis of 36 studies: goal setting improved sport and exercise performance by 0.34 SD overall; moderate, absolute, and combined short- and long-term goals were associated with the greatest effects.
27 applied (non-laboratory) goal-setting interventions with athletes from individual and team sports; mostly small samples focused on performance; goal-setting theory applied inconsistently with mixed support for goal characteristics (difficulty, specificity, proximity, source, type) and moderators. Calls for individualised interventions. Published online 2021, print 2023.
Two goal-setting training programmes (process- vs performance-oriented). The process-goal group improved in ability between tests and showed gains in self-efficacy, cognitive anxiety control and concentration in competition.
Five ability-matched groups of 8 on a soccer task (four goal-combination groups, one control) over 5 weeks of training then a competition; groups using multiple-goal strategies (outcome, performance and process) performed best in training and competition.
138 randomised studies (N = 19,951), mostly health and other non-sport behaviours. Interventions increased the frequency of progress monitoring (d = 1.98) and improved goal attainment (d = 0.40); effects were larger when progress was reported to others or made public and when it was physically recorded.