Recurrent injury, a lasting plateau, frequent plan breakdown or a step up in distance are reasonable signals that a static plan needs responsive adjustment, but no study shows which athletes benefit from a coach
Interpretation
No study tests readiness for coaching; each link is inference. Previous injury is the most consistent running-injury risk factor across 73 studies (Hulme 2017); evidence that sudden load jumps cause injury is very limited, from 4 studies (Damsted 2018); in 212 non-professional triathletes, competition carried far higher injury rates per hour than training (Zwingenberger 2014). Non-response in 78 healthy adults disappeared with a higher dose (Montero 2017), and HRV-timed hard sessions in 40 recreational runners gave a small advantage over a fixed plan with fewer hard sessions (Vesterinen 2016), consistent with Kiely's argument that rule-based planning fits individuals poorly (2012). In adults over 65, a few supervised sessions closed much of the supervised-unsupervised gap (Lacroix 2017). Populations are runners, healthy adults and older adults rather than triathletes, and sex splits are often unreported.
Practical implication
Treat a returning injury as a reason to see a clinician first, and two or more of these signs as a reasonable case for some coaching input, which may be a plan review, a short block or coached sessions in a weak discipline rather than full coaching. A decision framework inferred from adjacent evidence, not a tested rule.
Sources
7 sources, independently verified.
Argues that periodisation models share historical assumptions that are no longer scientifically justified, that individual training responses vary widely, and that planning should be flexible and context-specific rather than rule-based.
Systematic review of 73 studies of middle- and long-distance runners. A history of previous injury was associated with increased risk of both general and specific running-related injury; irregular or absent menstruation was linked to stress fracture and oral contraceptive use to lower risk. Most other training and behavioural factors gave inconsistent results, and heterogeneity prevented pooling. Runners, not triathletes.
Most injuries occurred running (50%), then cycling (43%) and swimming (7%). Injury incidence per 1000 h was 0.69 (retrospective) and 1.39 (prospective) in training versus 9.24 and 18.45 in competition; competing was the main risk factor. The retrospective design appeared to underestimate overuse injuries.
Only 4 eligible studies; 3 found an association between load increases and running injury. Increasing weekly distance by more than 30% vs under 10% gave HR 1.59 (95% CI 0.96 to 2.66); no difference between 10% and 24% average increases. The authors concluded that very limited evidence supports a link between sudden load changes and injury.
Prevalence of cardiorespiratory fitness non-response after 6 weeks fell as weekly dose increased. Non-responders completed a further 6 weeks with two extra sessions a week, after which non-response was abolished; improvement was mainly explained by haemoglobin mass. Healthy adults, not trained athletes.
Over an 8-week intensive period, the HRV-guided group did moderate or hard sessions only when morning HRV was within an individual range and did fewer of them (13.2 vs 17.7) than a predefined-plan group. 3000 m performance improved 2.1% (significant) vs 1.1% (not significant), a small between-group difference (ES 0.42); VO2max improved in both. Tests one adjustment method, not coaching.
11 studies of healthy adults aged 65 and over. Supervised balance and/or resistance training beat unsupervised training for muscle strength/power (SMD 0.51) and balance test batteries (SMD 0.53). Benefits were larger against fully unsupervised programmes (SMD 0.28 to 1.24) than against programmes with a few supervised sessions (-0.06 to 0.41). Few studies, median PEDro score 5.