Racing & Strategy ·

Grit and Mental Toughness: Trainable Skill or Rebranded Personality?

Grit overlaps heavily with conscientiousness and predicts performance only modestly. Mental toughness links more clearly to sport results, but its measures are messy. What survives the label, and what a triathlete can actually train.

Grit and Mental Toughness: Trainable Skill or Rebranded Personality?

Sprint Summary

The short version — read this if you're short on time.

Grit and mental toughness are everywhere in endurance culture, but the research behind them is less tidy than the slogans. A 2017 meta-analysis of 88 samples and 66,807 people found grit was very strongly correlated with conscientiousness, a long-established personality trait, and only moderately related to performance. The part that did most of the work was perseverance of effort, not passion. Mental toughness has a clearer link with sport results: a meta-analysis of 16 studies found a correlation of 0.36 overall and 0.32 in endurance sports, though these are correlations, measured with several different questionnaires.

For a triathlete, the useful message is that you don't need to become a different kind of person. Twin studies suggest about half the variation in mental toughness is genetic, and in 56 elite 100-mile runners, toughness scores were high but didn't predict who placed best. What looks more trainable are the specific behaviours underneath the label: turning up consistently, planning for bad patches, using coping skills under pressure, and knowing when stopping is the right call.

Safety & Context

Mental toughness is not the same as ignoring pain. Chest pain, unusual breathlessness, dizziness, confusion or sharp, localised pain that worsens during a session are reasons to stop, not tests of character. TriForward's "Bone Stress Injuries in Triathletes" covers bone pain warning signs.

Persisting through every planned session regardless of illness, injury or exhaustion is a risk factor for overtraining and burnout, not a sign of grit. If you feel persistently flat, low or unable to recover, see TriForward's "Motivation Slump or Burnout? Telling a Flat Patch From Something Bigger" and speak to your GP.

If a "tough it out" attitude extends to restricting food or training through repeated injuries, the pattern deserves a professional conversation. TriForward's "Under-Fuelled, Not Undertrained" covers low energy availability.

The evidence here comes mostly from students, soldiers, youth team sports and elite ultra runners, and is largely correlational. Treat it as a guide to what is worth practising, not proof that any mental skill will make you faster.

Full Distance

The complete research and analysis.

Every triathlete has a story about someone who was "just tougher". The training partner who finishes the long run in the rain, the athlete who walks the marathon but still crosses the line, the age-grouper who never seems to miss a session. It's tempting to treat that quality as a fixed trait you either have or don't, or as something you can build by forcing yourself through harder and harder sessions.

Two research ideas sit behind most of this talk: grit, popularised by Angela Duckworth, and mental toughness, a term sport psychologists have argued about for decades. This article looks at what each one actually measures, how well they predict performance, whether they can be trained, and what is worth taking from them into a triathlon season.

What grit is

Duckworth and colleagues defined grit in 2007 as perseverance and passion for long-term goals. Their questionnaire has two parts:

  • Perseverance of effort: finishing what you start, working hard through setbacks.
  • Consistency of interest: sticking with the same goals over years rather than switching to new ones.

The idea was that achievement in any field depends not just on talent but on sustained, focused effort over a long time. That fits triathlon neatly. Long-course racing in particular rewards years of steady training more than one heroic block.

The original evidence

The first paper, in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, used six samples:

  • Two adult samples (1,545 and 690 people), looking at educational attainment.
  • 138 Ivy League undergraduates, looking at grade point average.
  • Two classes of West Point cadets (1,218 and 1,308), looking at who completed the demanding first summer of training.
  • 175 National Spelling Bee finalists, looking at how far they got.

Grit accounted for an average of 4% of the variance in these success outcomes. It wasn't related to IQ, but it was highly correlated with conscientiousness, the Big Five personality trait covering organisation, dependability and self-discipline. The authors reported that grit still predicted success beyond IQ and conscientiousness.

Four per cent of variance is a real but small effect. Inference: if grit explained a similar share of differences in triathlon results, fitness, training history, body size, equipment and race-day conditions would account for far more. None of these samples were athletes, so even that comparison is a stretch.

What happened when the evidence was pooled

In 2017, Credé, Tynan and Harms published a meta-analysis of the grit literature in the same journal. It combined 584 effect sizes from 88 independent samples representing 66,807 people, mostly in education and work settings. Their main findings:

  • The two-part structure of grit wasn't confirmed. Perseverance and consistency of interest didn't behave like two facets of one higher-order trait.
  • Grit was only moderately correlated with performance and retention.
  • Grit was very strongly correlated with conscientiousness. So strongly that the authors questioned whether grit is really a new construct at all.
  • Perseverance of effort was the more useful facet. It predicted outcomes better than consistency of interest, and it still explained some variance in academic performance after accounting for conscientiousness.

The authors concluded that interventions designed to raise grit may have only weak effects on performance and success, and that the main value of the idea may lie in the perseverance facet. This is a textbook example of what psychologists call a "jangle" problem: a new name attached to something that largely overlaps with an existing, well-studied trait.

Grit in sport

Grit has been studied in athletes too, but mostly with questionnaires at a single point in time. A scoping review by Cormier and colleagues in the International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology found 90 publications on grit in sport. Most looked at how grit related to athlete sex, competitive level, performance, motivation, mindfulness, self-compassion and deliberate practice.

The review's main conclusions were about what's missing:

  • Measurement needs work. Questionnaires built for students and workers may not fit sport, and constructs that overlap with grit were common in the studies.
  • Interventions to raise athlete grit haven't been designed and tested properly.
  • Stronger designs are needed, rather than more one-off correlational surveys.

No study in the review was a trial showing that raising grit improved race results. That matters, because a correlation between grit and performance could mean that gritty people train more, or simply that people who are doing well in their sport rate themselves as more persistent.

What mental toughness is

Mental toughness has a longer history in sport psychology and a messier one. Different research groups have defined it differently, and there are several competing questionnaires. Common themes include confidence, a sense of control, commitment, coping with pressure, and keeping going when things get hard.

One concept or many?

Gucciardi and colleagues published five studies in the Journal of Personality (2015) to settle some of the arguments. They covered sport, education, the military and the workplace:

  • Study 1: 30 people.
  • Study 2: a calibration sample of 418, then 500 tertiary students, 427 athletes and 550 employees.
  • Study 3: 497 employees.
  • Study 4: 203 tertiary students.
  • Study 5: 115 army candidates.

They concluded that mental toughness is best seen as one dimension rather than many separate parts, that it plays a role in performance, goal progress and thriving under stress, and that it has both enduring and variable properties: fairly stable over time, but also varying across situations. In other words, it behaves partly like a personality trait and partly like a state.

How much is inherited?

A 2017 systematic review by Lin and colleagues in Frontiers in Psychology pulled together studies linking mental toughness to performance in education and work, well-being and personality. Mental toughness was associated with positive traits, more efficient coping and better outcomes in education and mental health. The review also reported that about 50% of the variation in mental toughness can be accounted for by genetic factors, based on twin studies.

That figure is often misread. It doesn't mean half of your toughness is fixed and half is up to you. It means that, across a population, about half of the differences between people are associated with genetic differences. Inference: the other half reflects environment and experience, which leaves plenty of room for practice and context to matter.

Does mental toughness predict performance?

The best summary for sport is a meta-analysis by Hsieh and colleagues in the International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology (published online 2023). It examined 16 studies published between 2000 and 2022.

  • Overall correlation between mental toughness and athletic performance: r = 0.36, a moderate relationship.
  • By age: 0.20 in adolescents and 0.41 in adults.
  • By sport: 0.73 in combat sports, 0.30 in ball sports and 0.32 in endurance sports.
  • By sport type: 0.73 for individual sports and 0.21 for team sports.
  • By performance measure: 0.33 for objective measures such as times or results, and 0.62 for subjective measures such as coach ratings.
  • By questionnaire: correlations ranged from 0.13 to 0.56 depending on which instrument was used.

Two details deserve attention. First, the link with objective performance (0.33) is much weaker than with subjective ratings (0.62). Inference: some of the apparent effect may come from coaches rating athletes they already see as successful as "tough". Second, the size of the relationship depends heavily on which questionnaire is used, which supports the criticism that mental toughness means different things in different studies.

Sixteen studies is also a small evidence base, and all of it is correlational. These numbers say that tougher-rated athletes tend to perform better, not that becoming tougher will make you faster.

Elite ultra runners

The most triathlon-adjacent study is a 2020 paper in PLoS ONE by Brace, George and Lovell. 56 elite ultra-marathon runners (38 men, 18 women; mean age 39) completed mental toughness and endurance self-efficacy questionnaires before the HURT100, a 100-mile trail race in Hawaii.

  • Mental toughness and self-efficacy were closely related (r = 0.72).
  • Neither predicted performance: not world ranking, not likelihood of finishing, not placing, not finishing time.
  • Mental toughness scores were higher than those previously published for athletes in other sports.

The authors suggested there may be a threshold of mental toughness needed to prepare for and compete in such events, and that once it is met, other factors decide the result. Inference: for triathletes who are already training consistently and finishing races, more "toughness" may matter less than fitness, pacing and fuelling. One race and 56 runners is a narrow base, though.

Can it be trained?

The intervention evidence is thin and comes mainly from young team-sport athletes. In a 2009 study in the Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, Gucciardi, Gordon and Dimmock compared two psychological skills training programmes with a control group across three under-15 Australian football teams:

  • A programme built around the "keys" to mental toughness the researchers had identified earlier.
  • A traditional psychological skills programme covering self-regulation, arousal regulation, mental rehearsal, attentional control, self-efficacy and ideal performance state.

Both intervention groups reported more positive changes in mental toughness, resilience and flow than the control group, and parents and coaches gave similar ratings. The two programmes were about equally effective.

That last point is the useful one. Teaching ordinary mental skills raised mental toughness as much as a programme designed around toughness itself. Inference: "mental toughness" may be best understood as the visible result of a set of learnable skills, rather than a separate quality you train directly. The study measured ratings of toughness, not match performance, and the participants were boys in a team sport, so transfer to adult endurance athletes is unknown.

What's useful under the label

Strip away the branding and a few practical ideas survive the evidence reasonably well:

  • Perseverance of effort is the part that predicts. For a triathlete, that looks like turning up week after week. TriForward's "Habits Beat Motivation: How Training Routines Form, and How Long It Takes" covers how routines make that easier.
  • Conscientiousness-type behaviours matter. Planning sessions, preparing kit the night before and following a structured plan are the everyday form of what grit questionnaires measure.
  • Specific mental skills are trainable. Self-talk, attentional focus and imagery have their own evidence bases. See TriForward's "Self-Talk That Works: What to Say to Yourself When It Gets Hard" and "Where to Put Your Attention: Internal vs External Focus in a Long Race".
  • Coping plans beat character. Deciding in advance what you'll do when the run falls apart is more actionable than hoping to be tough. TriForward's "Controlling the Controllables: Weather, Punctures and Other Things You Can't Change" covers if-then planning.

Toughness includes knowing when to back off

Endurance culture often treats toughness as refusing to stop. The research definitions are broader. Gucciardi's work links mental toughness to goal progress and thriving under stress, and Credé's analysis points to perseverance of effort over years, not in a single session. Neither describes ignoring warning signs.

Inference: for an age-grouper, the persistence that matters is the kind that keeps you training across a season. Missing one session because you're ill, or easing off after a poor night's sleep, protects that long-term consistency. Grinding through every planned session regardless of how you feel can do the opposite, and TriForward's "Perfectionism and the Missed Session: When High Standards Help and When They Hurt" covers why trying to "make up" missed work tends to backfire.

A triathlon scenario

This example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 44-year-old age-grouper training for his first full-distance race believes he "isn't mentally tough". He fades badly in the final 10 km of long runs and has abandoned two half-distance races on the run.

Rather than trying to become a tougher person, he works through the specifics:

  • Consistency first: fixed session times, three weeks of steady training before adding volume.
  • Pacing and fuelling: he checks whether the fade is physiological. TriForward's "Why the Ironman Marathon Falls Apart After 25 km" and the fuelling guides suggest much late-race "weakness" is pacing and carbohydrate, not character.
  • A bad-patch plan: a short self-talk phrase, a rule to walk aid stations, and a focus on the next aid station rather than the finish.
  • A stop list: chest pain, dizziness, confusion or sharp localised pain means stopping, decided before the race. TriForward's "When to Pull the Plug: Making the DNF Decision Mid-Race" covers this.

Common mistakes

  • Treating toughness as a fixed trait. About half the variation is genetic in twin studies, which leaves a lot that isn't.
  • Confusing toughness with never stopping. None of the studies here measured training through injury or illness, and doing so is a route to injury and burnout.
  • Using "hard" sessions to build character. There's no evidence that suffering more in training builds a transferable toughness trait. Train to your plan.
  • Blaming mindset for physiology. Late-race fades are often pacing, fuelling or heat.
  • Buying grit programmes. The meta-analysis suggests effects on performance are likely to be weak.

What we don't know

  • Whether grit or mental toughness predicts triathlon results. No triathlon-specific studies were found.
  • Whether training mental toughness improves endurance performance. The intervention evidence measures ratings of toughness, mostly in youth team sports.
  • Cause and effect. Nearly all the sport evidence is correlational.
  • Sex and age differences. The ultra-running study included 18 women; most other sport studies don't report results by sex for the questions covered here.
  • Which questionnaire to trust. Results vary considerably with the measure used.

References

  • Duckworth AL, Peterson C, Matthews MD, Kelly DR. Grit: perseverance and passion for long-term goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2007;92(6):1087–1101. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.92.6.1087
  • Credé M, Tynan MC, Harms PD. Much ado about grit: a meta-analytic synthesis of the grit literature. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2017;113(3):492–511. doi:10.1037/pspp0000102
  • Cormier DL, Ferguson LJ, Gyurcsik NC, Briere JL, Dunn JGH, Kowalski KC. Grit in sport: a scoping review. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2024;17(1):1–38. doi:10.1080/1750984X.2021.1934887
  • Gucciardi DF, Hanton S, Gordon S, Mallett CJ, Temby P. The concept of mental toughness: tests of dimensionality, nomological network, and traitness. Journal of Personality, 2015;83(1):26–44. doi:10.1111/jopy.12079
  • Lin Y, Mutz J, Clough PJ, Papageorgiou KA. Mental toughness and individual differences in learning, educational and work performance, psychological well-being, and personality: a systematic review. Frontiers in Psychology, 2017;8:1345. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01345
  • Hsieh YC, Lu FJH, Gill DL, Hsu YW, Wong TL, Kuan G. Effects of mental toughness on athletic performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2024;22(6):1317–1338. doi:10.1080/1612197X.2023.2204312
  • Brace AW, George K, Lovell GP. Mental toughness and self-efficacy of elite ultra-marathon runners. PLoS ONE, 2020;15(11):e0241284. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0241284
  • Gucciardi DF, Gordon S, Dimmock JA. Evaluation of a mental toughness training program for youth-aged Australian footballers: I. A quantitative analysis. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 2009;21(3):307–323. doi:10.1080/10413200903026066

Frequently asked questions

Is grit different from conscientiousness?

Not by much. A meta-analysis of 88 samples and 66,807 people found grit very strongly correlated with conscientiousness and only moderately related to performance. The perseverance part of grit did most of the predicting.

Does mental toughness predict triathlon performance?

There is no triathlon-specific evidence. A meta-analysis of 16 sport studies found a moderate link overall (r = 0.36) and a similar one in endurance sports (r = 0.32), but these are correlations, not proof that mental toughness causes better results.

Can you train mental toughness?

Some small studies, mostly in youth team sports, show psychological skills programmes raise self-rated mental toughness. Whether that improves endurance race times hasn't been tested. Specific skills such as planning, self-talk and coping routines are a more practical target than the label.

Are tough athletes the ones who never miss a session?

No. Persistence is useful, but so is knowing when to back off. Training through illness, pain or exhaustion is a route to injury and burnout, and isn't what the research measures as mental toughness.

The evidence behind this guide

1 graded principle, 8 sources. Open one to see the sources.

Grit largely overlaps with conscientiousness and predicts performance only modestly, while mental toughness correlates moderately with sport performance but has not been shown to cause faster endurance resultsLimited evidence8 sources

In practice: Treat grit and mental toughness as labels for trainable behaviours rather than traits to acquire: build consistent training routines, plan for bad patches, practise specific skills such as self-talk, and decide stop rules in advance. Inference from non-triathlete and correlational evidence; there is no evidence that 'toughness training' makes age-group triathletes faster, and toughness never means ignoring pain or illness.

Peer-reviewed studyObservationalIndependently verified
Grit: perseverance and passion for long-term goals ↗
Duckworth AL, Peterson C, Matthews MD, Kelly DR · 2007 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Six non-athlete samples: adults (1,545 and 690), Ivy League undergraduates (138), West Point cadets (1,218 and 1,308), National Spelling Bee finalists (175); sex split not reported in abstract

Six samples: grit explained an average of 4% of variance in success outcomes (educational attainment, GPA, West Point retention, spelling bee ranking), was unrelated to IQ, was highly correlated with Big Five conscientiousness, and showed incremental validity beyond IQ and conscientiousness. Non-athletes; sex split not reported in abstract.

Meta-analysisIndependently verified
Much ado about grit: a meta-analytic synthesis of the grit literature ↗
Credé M, Tynan MC, Harms PD · 2017 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
88 independent samples, 66,807 individuals, mostly students and workers; sex split not reported in abstract

584 effect sizes from 88 independent samples (66,807 individuals, mostly education and work). The higher-order two-facet structure of grit was not confirmed; grit was only moderately correlated with performance and retention and very strongly correlated with conscientiousness; perseverance of effort had stronger criterion validity than consistency of interest and explained academic performance beyond conscientiousness. Authors conclude grit interventions may have only weak effects. Exact pooled coefficients not used (abstract-level only).

Systematic reviewIndependently verified
Grit in sport: a scoping review ↗
Cormier DL, Ferguson LJ, Gyurcsik NC, Briere JL, Dunn JGH, Kowalski KC · 2024 · International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology

Scoping review of 90 publications on grit in sport, mostly examining grit alongside athlete sex, competitive level, performance, motivation, mindfulness, self-compassion and deliberate practice. Identified grit measurement problems in sport, overlapping constructs, and a lack of designed and tested interventions; calls for stronger designs. Published online 2021, print issue 2024;17(1):1-38.

Peer-reviewed studyCross-sectionalIndependently verified
The concept of mental toughness: tests of dimensionality, nomological network, and traitness ↗
Gucciardi DF, Hanton S, Gordon S, Mallett CJ, Temby P · 2015 · Journal of Personality
Five studies: n = 30; calibration 418, tertiary students 500, athletes 427, employees 550; 497 employees; 203 students; 115 army candidates; sex split not reported in abstract

Five studies across sport, education, military and work concluded mental toughness is best conceptualised as unidimensional, plays a role in performance, goal progress and thriving despite stress, and has both enduring and situation-variable properties.

Systematic reviewIndependently verified
Mental toughness and individual differences in learning, educational and work performance, psychological well-being, and personality: a systematic review ↗
Lin Y, Mutz J, Clough PJ, Papageorgiou KA · 2017 · Frontiers in Psychology

Mental toughness associated with positive psychological traits, more efficient coping and positive education and mental health outcomes; approximately 50% of variation in mental toughness accounted for by genetic factors (twin studies). Mostly non-athlete samples.

Meta-analysisIndependently verified
Effects of mental toughness on athletic performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis ↗
Hsieh YC, Lu FJH, Gill DL, Hsu YW, Wong TL, Kuan G · 2024 · International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology
16 correlational sport studies; sex split not reported in abstract

16 studies (2000-2022), random effects: overall mental toughness-performance correlation r = 0.36; adolescents 0.20 vs adults 0.41; combat 0.73, ball 0.30, endurance sports 0.32; individual 0.73 vs team 0.21; objective performance measures 0.33 vs subjective 0.62; by questionnaire 0.13 to 0.56. Correlational evidence only. Published online 2023, print 2024;22(6):1317-1338.

Peer-reviewed studyCross-sectionalIndependently verified
Mental toughness and self-efficacy of elite ultra-marathon runners ↗
Brace AW, George K, Lovell GP · 2020 · PLoS ONE
56 elite ultra-marathon runners (38 M, 18 F; mean age 38.9 y)

At the HURT100 100-mile trail race, mental toughness and endurance self-efficacy were highly related (r = 0.72) but neither predicted world ranking, likelihood of finishing, placing or finishing time. Mental toughness was higher than published values for other sports; authors propose a threshold beyond which other factors decide performance. Single race, cross-sectional.

Peer-reviewed studyIndependently verified
Evaluation of a mental toughness training program for youth-aged Australian footballers: I. A quantitative analysis ↗
Gucciardi DF, Gordon S, Dimmock JA · 2009 · Journal of Applied Sport Psychology
Three under-15 Australian football teams (boys); individual n not reported in abstract

Two psychological skills training packages (one built on mental toughness 'keys', one traditional PST covering self-regulation, arousal regulation, mental rehearsal, attentional control, self-efficacy) vs control. Both intervention groups reported more positive changes in mental toughness, resilience and flow than control; parent and coach ratings similar; the two packages were equally effective. Outcomes were ratings, not performance.

Full write-up of this principle

Get The Forward

Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.