Swim ·

Why You're Slower in Open Water: Walls, Sighting and the Pool-to-Lake Gap

Most triathletes swim slower per 100 m in a lake than in the pool. Push-offs, a longer line, sighting and conditions all add time, while drafting and a wetsuit take some back. How to turn pool pace into a realistic open-water target.

Why You're Slower in Open Water: Walls, Sighting and the Pool-to-Lake Gap

Sprint Summary

The short version — read this if you're short on time.

Most triathletes swim slower per 100 m in a lake than in the pool, and the main reason is the walls. Every push-off is free speed: in one study of 11 male swimmers, mean speed over 400 m was 5.2% higher in a 25 m pool than in a 50 m pool at the same relative effort, and open water has no walls at all. On top of that you swim further than the course, because nobody holds a perfect line (even five elite swimmers covered a median 10,262 m in a 10 km race), and you lift your head to sight, deal with waves, cold and other swimmers, and may change your stroke: elite triathletes used a shorter, faster stroke in open water than in the pool.

None of this means your pool fitness doesn't count. In 14 elite triathletes, the fastest over 1,500 m in the pool were also the fastest in open water. Inference: as a starting estimate, take your 25 m pool pace, add about 5% for the lost walls and a few per cent for extra distance, then adjust for a wetsuit and drafting, which can win time back. Check it on a known course, practise sighting and continuous swimming in the pool, and never swim in open water alone.

Safety & Context

Never swim in open water alone. Swim at a supervised venue or with others, wear a bright cap and consider a tow float, and know how to signal for help (roll on your back and raise an arm). In a study of US triathlons, most sudden deaths and cardiac arrests happened during the swim.

Cold water is a hazard in its own right, separate from pace. Enter gradually, let your breathing settle before you start swimming hard, and get out if you start shivering hard, can't feel your hands or feel confused. TriForward's "15.0°C: The New Cold-Water Number (And Why the Rules Still Say 16)" covers the cold-water rules.

Don't chase a pool-based pace in open water at the expense of sighting. Swimming off course, into other swimmers or into hazards costs more than a few seconds, and checking where you are is part of swimming safely.

Chest pain, unusual breathlessness, coughing up frothy or pink fluid, or feeling faint during or after a swim needs medical attention, not more swimming.

Full Distance

The complete research and analysis.

Your pool sessions say you swim 1,500 m in 27 minutes. Your first open-water race of the season says 31. The course may have been long, but probably not by four minutes. So where did the time go?

Almost every triathlete notices the gap between pool and open-water pace. It's easy to put it down to nerves, cold or a bad day. Some of it may be, and TriForward's "Open Water Sighting and Race-Start Anxiety: Why It's a Physiology Problem, Not Just a Mental Game" and "Afraid of Open Water: Building Confidence Before Race Season" cover that side. But a lot of the gap is built into the difference between swimming between walls and swimming in a lake or the sea.

This guide breaks the gap into its parts, looks at what research measures for each, and shows how to turn a pool pace into a realistic open-water target. No study has measured the full pool-to-lake gap in age-group triathletes, so the conversion at the end is inference.

The parts of the gap

Five things separate pool pace from open-water pace:

  1. Walls. Pool swimming includes a push-off every length. Open water has none.
  2. Distance. In the pool, 1,500 m is exactly 1,500 m. In open water, you swim further than the course because you don't swim in a perfectly straight line.
  3. Sighting. Lifting your head to look forward breaks your rhythm and body position.
  4. Conditions. Waves, chop, currents, cold and other swimmers all affect speed and stroke.
  5. Kit and company. A wetsuit and drafting behind other swimmers both make you faster, and can offset some of the losses.

Walls: the free speed you leave behind

What the pool-length studies show

The cleanest evidence on walls comes from comparing 25 m and 50 m pools, which differ only in the number of turns.

A 2026 study by Bosetto and colleagues in the European Journal of Applied Physiology tested 11 male swimmers doing five 400 m front-crawl trials at 70 to 86% of race speed, in both a 25 m and a 50 m pool, paced by underwater lights.

  • At the same relative intensity, mean speed was 5.2% higher in the 25 m pool.
  • At the same absolute speed, the energy cost of swimming was about 4% higher in the 50 m pool. Turns made the swim cheaper.
  • Heart rate, lactate and perceived effort didn't differ at matched relative intensities.

An older study by Keskinen and colleagues in 2007, in the International Journal of Sports Medicine, tested 11 male swimmers doing 5 x 200 m from easy to maximal in both pool lengths.

  • Maximum speed was 4.5% higher in the 25 m pool.
  • At submaximal speeds, heart rate was 7.3 beats per minute lower in the 25 m pool, and blood lactate was lower too.
  • The turn itself added about 8.1% to speed compared with the swimming just before it, in short all-out swims.

Both studies were in trained male swimmers, so the exact numbers may differ for age-group triathletes, women and swimmers with less polished turns. But the direction is clear: walls make swimming faster and easier.

What that means for open water

A 50 m pool still has a wall every 50 m. Open water has none. Inference: if moving from a 25 m to a 50 m pool costs about 5% of speed at the same effort, losing the walls entirely probably costs at least that, and possibly more. Swimmers with strong push-offs and tumble turns gain the most from walls, so they may also lose the most in open water. Swimmers who do open turns and short push-offs may notice a smaller gap.

There's a second, quieter effect. Each wall gives you a brief rest from the stroke: a couple of seconds of glide with your face down and arms extended. Over a 1,500 m pool swim in a 25 m pool, that is 59 short breaks. Open water gives you none. Inference: this may be part of why open-water swims feel harder at the same pace, and why the Keskinen study found heart rate lower in the shorter pool.

Distance: nobody swims a straight line

A race course of 1,500 m is measured buoy to buoy. You swim it with a slight zig-zag, wide around buoys, round other swimmers and with any current pushing you sideways.

Direct measurements in age-group triathletes don't exist. The best data come from elite open-water swimmers. A 2026 study by Pla and Bouvet in the Journal of Sports Sciences tracked five elite or world-class swimmers with satellite positioning devices through a 10 km national championship race.

  • They covered a median 10,262 m.
  • Their paths varied a lot between swimmers and over the race, including around buoys and feeding stations.

Inference: that is about 2.6% further than the nominal race distance, in swimmers who navigate for a living. Course measurement also has its own error, so not all of that is swimmer navigation. Age-groupers who sight less well, swim in a crowd or veer to one side are likely to add more. TriForward's "Swim Watches and Trackers: How Accurate Are Lengths, Distance and Wrist Heart Rate in Water?" explains why your watch's open-water distance is a rough guide rather than a measurement, so you can't simply read your extra distance off your wrist.

Sighting: the cost of looking where you're going

To swim straight, you have to look. Most triathletes lift their eyes forward every few strokes. That lift tends to drop the hips and legs, interrupts the stroke and, if you breathe forward, changes your breathing rhythm.

TriForward found no peer-reviewed study that directly measures how much time or energy sighting costs. Inference from how drag works in swimming: a lifted head and dropped legs increase the frontal area you push through the water, so every sight probably costs a little speed. The trade-off is that sighting too rarely costs far more in extra distance. The practical answer is to sight efficiently rather than rarely: eyes just above the surface, quick, and timed into the stroke.

Conditions and stroke changes

Open water also changes how you swim. A 2024 study by López-Belmonte and colleagues in the Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports had 14 elite triathletes (10 men, 4 women, average age 23) swim 1,500 m in open water and in a 25 m pool.

  • In open water, stroke length was shorter and stroke rate higher than in the pool.
  • Heart rate, blood lactate and oxygen uptake didn't differ between conditions.
  • The fastest triathletes in open water were the fastest in the pool (a very strong correlation, r = 0.958).

The authors suggested triathletes adapt their technique to open water, which is consistent with what coaches see: a shorter, quicker stroke helps in chop and when sighting. TriForward's "Stroke Rate vs. Distance-Per-Stroke: What the Research Actually Says" covers that trade-off. The abstract doesn't report the speed difference between conditions, so this study can't tell you how big the gap is, only that the physiological effort was similar and the stroke changed.

Waves, currents, cold water, murky water you can't see through and swimmers around you will all add to the gap on some days and not others. They're hard to study and change from race to race.

They also matter for safety, not just pace. A 2017 case series by Harris and colleagues in the Annals of Internal Medicine found that of 135 deaths and cardiac arrests in US triathlons between 1985 and 2016, 90 sudden deaths or arrests happened during the swim. Inference: the swim is where supervision, a sensible start and knowing how to signal for help matter most, whatever your pace.

Does pool fitness still count?

Yes. Apart from the very strong link in the López-Belmonte study, a 2023 study by Sellés-Pérez and colleagues in the Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology followed 18 male triathletes (3 world-class, 10 elite or international, 5 national level) across 61 pool lactate tests and 75 races. Speeds at lactate thresholds and in the final repeat of a pool test were moderately to strongly linked with swim times and positions in races at most levels, though not all.

Both studies were in elite athletes. Inference: if anything, pool fitness should matter even more for age-groupers, whose swim times vary more, but the gap from open-water skills may also be bigger.

What wins time back

Drafting

Swimming on someone's feet is the biggest legal advantage in open water. A 2003 study by Chatard and Wilson in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise tested 11 swimmers at 95% of their 1,500 m pace. In towing tests, passive drag fell by 21% directly behind another swimmer's toes, and oxygen uptake, heart rate, lactate and perceived effort were lower in every drafting position. TriForward's "Learning to Draft in the Pool: Practising Feet-Swimming Over Winter" covers how to use it.

A wetsuit

In most age-group races, the wetsuit is the other big offset. TriForward's "How Much Faster Is a Wetsuit? Buoyancy, Drag and the Real Time Saving" covers the size of the gain, and "Who Gains Most From a Wetsuit? Why Weaker Swimmers Get More Free Speed" covers who benefits most. Inference: when you compare pool and open-water pace, compare like with like, because a wetsuit swim and a non-wetsuit swim aren't the same event.

Turning pool pace into an open-water target

None of this has been tested as a conversion in triathletes. The following is inference, built from the studies above.

  1. Start with a recent pool pace you can hold for the race distance, for example from a timed swim or a critical swim speed test. TriForward's "Critical Swim Speed: Setting Swim Intensity Without a Coach on Deck" explains the test.
  2. Add about 5% for losing the walls, if your pool pace is from a 25 m pool. Use less if it's from a 50 m pool.
  3. Add a few per cent for extra distance, more if your sighting is weak or the course has many turns.
  4. Take some back for a wetsuit, and a little more if you draft well.
  5. Check it on a known open-water course in training, with others and with supervision, and adjust.

A worked example

Inference, using round numbers: a swimmer holds 1:50 per 100 m for 1,500 m in a 25 m pool, about 27 minutes 30 seconds.

  • Without walls, 5% slower is about 1:56 per 100 m.
  • Swimming 3% further, the 1,500 m course becomes about 1,545 m swum.
  • At about 1:56 per 100 m over 1,545 m, that's just under 30 minutes before any wetsuit or drafting benefit.

So a gap of two or three minutes over 1,500 m isn't a sign of poor form. A wetsuit and good drafting might bring the time back close to, or under, the pool time. The numbers will differ for you, which is why step 5 matters.

Training to close the gap

  1. Sight in the pool. Lift your eyes every six to ten strokes in some main sets, so the movement becomes cheap and automatic.
  2. Swim some continuous sets without pushing hard off the walls, or with an open turn and no glide.
  3. Swim on someone's feet in a lane, and practise swimming beside another swimmer.
  4. Practise starts and buoy turns in open water sessions, where the course allows.
  5. Get regular open-water time before races, at supervised venues.

A triathlon scenario

The following example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 38-year-old age-grouper swims 1:45 per 100 m in his 25 m pool and expects about 26 minutes for his first standard-distance race. He comes out in 29 minutes and decides his swim training isn't working.

Looking at it piece by piece:

  • His pool times include 59 push-offs for 1,500 m, which open water doesn't offer.
  • His watch traced a wandering line, with a wide swing at the first buoy.
  • He sighted rarely, then had to correct course several times.
  • He swam alone at the side of the pack rather than on anyone's feet.

His fitness is fine. For his next race, he practises sighting every eight strokes in the pool, swims two supervised lake sessions on a measured loop, and aims to find feet early. He sets a realistic target of 27 to 28 minutes in a wetsuit.

Common mistakes

  • Expecting pool pace in open water and treating a slower time as a failure.
  • Sighting too rarely to save energy, then swimming much further.
  • Training only in the pool until race day.
  • Comparing wetsuit open-water times with pool times as if they were the same.
  • Trusting watch distance to measure how far off course you swam.
  • Swimming in open water alone.

What we don't know

  • The full pool-to-open-water gap in age-group triathletes, which hasn't been measured directly.
  • How much sighting costs, in time or energy.
  • How far age-groupers actually swim compared with the course length.
  • Whether the turn effect differs for women, older swimmers and those with less polished turns; both pool-length studies were in trained men.
  • How conditions such as chop and cold change the gap from race to race.

References

  • Bosetto P, Coloretti V, Lubrano M, Bonifazi M, Zamparo P, Fantozzi S, Cortesi M. Swimming turns reduce energy demands of the aerobic performance in front crawl. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2026;126(5):2491–2500. doi:10.1007/s00421-025-06084-7
  • Keskinen OP, Keskinen KL, Mero AA. Effect of pool length on blood lactate, heart rate, and velocity in swimming. International Journal of Sports Medicine, 2007;28(5):407–413. doi:10.1055/s-2006-924505
  • López-Belmonte Ó, Ruiz-Navarro JJ, Gay A, Cuenca-Fernández F, Arellano R, Cejuela R. Swimming performance in elite triathletes: comparison between open water and pool conditions. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 2024;34(8):e14702. doi:10.1111/sms.14702
  • Sellés-Pérez S, Cejuela R, Fernández-Sáez J, Arévalo-Chico H. Does pool performance of elite triathletes predict open-water performance? Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology, 2023;8(4):165. doi:10.3390/jfmk8040165
  • Pla R, Bouvet A. An exploratory study of pacing and trajectories in elite open-water swimming using GPS and critical velocity modeling. Journal of Sports Sciences, 2026;44(6):741–755. doi:10.1080/02640414.2025.2605425
  • Chatard JC, Wilson B. Drafting distance in swimming. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2003;35(7):1176–1181. doi:10.1249/01.MSS.0000074564.06106.1F
  • Harris KM, Creswell LL, Haas TS, Thomas T, Tung M, Isaacson E, Garberich RF, Maron BJ. Death and cardiac arrest in U.S. triathlon participants, 1985 to 2016: a case series. Annals of Internal Medicine, 2017;167(8):529–535. doi:10.7326/M17-0847

Frequently asked questions

Why is my open-water pace slower than my pool pace?

Mainly because there are no walls. Push-offs and turns make pool swimming faster: in one study of 11 male swimmers, mean speed was 5.2% higher in a 25 m pool than a 50 m pool at the same effort. In open water you also swim further than the course length, lift your head to sight, and deal with waves, cold and other swimmers.

How much slower should I expect to be in open water?

No study has measured this in age-group triathletes, so any number is an estimate. As a rough guide, expect to be about 5% slower than your 25 m pool pace from losing the walls alone, plus whatever extra distance you swim by not holding a straight line. A wetsuit and good drafting can win some or all of that back.

Does pool fitness predict open-water swim times?

Yes, reasonably well. In 14 elite triathletes, the fastest over 1,500 m in the pool were also the fastest in open water, and in 18 male triathletes, pool lactate-test speeds predicted race swim times at most race levels. Open water changes your stroke, but it doesn't cancel your fitness.

How do I train for the open-water gap in the pool?

Practise sighting every few strokes during main sets, do some continuous swims without pushing off hard, practise swimming on someone's feet, and swim some sets with no wall rest. Then check a realistic pace in open water on a known course, with others and with supervision.

The evidence behind this guide

1 graded principle, 7 sources. Open one to see the sources.

Open-water swim pace is slower than pool pace mainly because walls make pool swimming faster and open-water swimmers cover more than the course distance, while pool fitness still predicts open-water speedLimited evidence7 sources

In practice: Expect a slower open-water pace than 25 m pool pace (roughly 5% from walls plus a few per cent for extra distance, offset by wetsuit and drafting), practise sighting and continuous swimming in the pool, verify a target on a known supervised course, and never swim open water alone. The conversion is inference from pool-length studies in trained men and elite open-water data.

Peer-reviewed studyIndependently verified
Swimming turns reduce energy demands of the aerobic performance in front crawl ↗
Bosetto P, Coloretti V, Lubrano M, Bonifazi M, Zamparo P, Fantozzi S, Cortesi M · 2026 · European Journal of Applied Physiology
11 male swimmers, five 400 m front-crawl trials at 70-86% of race velocity in 25 m and 50 m pools

At equivalent relative intensity, mean velocity was 5.2% higher in the 25 m than the 50 m pool (+0.07 m/s) with no differences in kinematic, physiological or energetic variables; at matched absolute speeds energy cost was about 4% higher in the 50 m pool. Turns make swimming more economical. Men only; trained swimmers.

Peer-reviewed studyIndependently verified
Effect of pool length on blood lactate, heart rate, and velocity in swimming ↗
Keskinen OP, Keskinen KL, Mero AA · 2007 · International Journal of Sports Medicine
11 male swimmers, 5 x 200 m incremental freestyle in 25 m and 50 m pools

Maximum velocity 4.5% greater in the 25 m pool (1.38 vs 1.32 m/s); blood lactate higher in the 50 m pool at every point; heart rate 7.3 ± 0.7 bpm lower in the 25 m pool at submaximal speeds; turning benefit 8.1 ± 3.2% in short all-out swims, correlated with the short-long velocity difference. Men only.

Peer-reviewed studyIndependently verified
Swimming performance in elite triathletes: comparison between open water and pool conditions ↗
López-Belmonte Ó, Ruiz-Navarro JJ, Gay A, Cuenca-Fernández F, Arellano R, Cejuela R · 2024 · Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports
14 elite triathletes (10 M, 4 F), 23.4 ± 3.8 y

1,500 m tests in open water and a 25 m pool: lower stroke length and stroke index and higher stroke rate in open water; no differences in heart rate, lactate or end-exercise oxygen uptake; RER lower and VO2 time constant higher in open water; fastest in open water were fastest in the pool (r = 0.958). Speed difference between conditions not reported in the abstract. Elite athletes.

Peer-reviewed studyObservationalIndependently verified
Does pool performance of elite triathletes predict open-water performance? ↗
Sellés-Pérez S, Cejuela R, Fernández-Sáez J, Arévalo-Chico H · 2023 · Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology
18 male triathletes (3 world-class, 10 elite/international, 5 national); 61 pool tests, 75 races

Speeds at LT1, LT2 and the last 200 m repeat of a graded pool lactate test showed moderate-to-strong associations with swim-leg time and position at most race levels, with no or weak-to-moderate correlations in some sprint and continental/world cup races. Men only, elite.

Peer-reviewed studyCase studyIndependently verified
An exploratory study of pacing and trajectories in elite open-water swimming using GPS and critical velocity modeling ↗
Pla R, Bouvet A · 2026 · Journal of Sports Sciences
5 elite or world-class open-water swimmers, French national 10 km championship

1 Hz GNSS tracking through a 10 km race: swimmers covered a median 10,262 m [10,259-10,268], with substantial intra- and inter-individual variability in pacing and trajectories around buoys and feeding stations. Exploratory; elite swimmers; course-measurement error not separated from navigation.

Peer-reviewed studyIndependently verified
Drafting distance in swimming ↗
Chatard JC, Wilson B · 2003 · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
11 swimmers at 95% of best 1500 m pace; passive drag towing in 6 swimmers (sex and level not given in abstract)

MSSE 35(7):1176–1181. 4-minute swims alone and drafting at 0, 50, 100 and 150 cm behind a lead swimmer: oxygen uptake, heart rate, lactate, RPE and stroke rate lower and stroke length longer in every drafting position. Passive drag fell 21% at 0 cm and 20% at 50 cm behind the toes; lateral drafting cut drag 6–7% at 50–100 cm behind the lead swimmer's hands. Best: 0–50 cm behind toes, or 50–100 cm behind hands at the side.

Peer-reviewed studyObservationalIndependently verified
Death and cardiac arrest in U.S. triathlon participants, 1985 to 2016: a case series ↗
Harris KM, Creswell LL, Haas TS, Thomas T, Tung M, Isaacson E, Garberich RF, Maron BJ · 2017 · Annals of Internal Medicine
135 deaths and cardiac arrests among US triathlon participants, 1985-2016 (85% male, mean age 46.7 y); incidence from 4,776,443 USAT participants 2006-2016

Annals of Internal Medicine 167(8):529-535. 135 sudden deaths, resuscitated cardiac arrests and trauma deaths in US triathlons 1985-2016; mean age 46.7 y, 85% male. Sudden deaths and arrests: 90 in the swim, 7 bike, 15 run, 8 post-race; 15 trauma deaths on the bike. Incidence in USAT races 2006-2016 (4,776,443 participants) 1.74 per 100,000 (men 2.40, women 0.74), 18.6 per 100,000 in men aged 60+; similar across race distances. 27 of 61 autopsies (44%) showed clinically relevant cardiovascular abnormalities, mostly coronary disease or cardiomyopathy. Case finding may be incomplete; pre-race medical history mostly unknown.

Full write-up of this principle

Get The Forward

Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.