Self-Talk That Works: What to Say to Yourself When It Gets Hard
Self-talk is one of the better-evidenced mental skills, with a meta-analysis and several small cycling trials behind it. What the studies found, why practice matters, where a race trial found nothing, and how to build your own cues.
Sprint Summary
The short version — read this if you're short on time.
Self-talk, the things you say to yourself in your head or under your breath, is one of the better-evidenced mental skills in sport. A 2011 meta-analysis of 32 studies found a moderate positive effect on performance, and it was larger when athletes had practised their self-talk. In endurance, small cycling trials found that two weeks of motivational self-talk training extended time to exhaustion (from 637 to 750 seconds in 24 people) and made a 10 km time trial faster in 14 men, often while effort felt the same or easier.
The caveats matter. The trials are small and mostly in young men cycling in a lab, and the one randomised trial in a real race, 29 runners in a 60-mile ultramarathon, found no performance effect, although most runners kept using the technique. The practical message is modest: write a few short phrases that answer the thoughts you actually have when it hurts, practise them in hard training, and never use them to talk yourself past genuine warning signs.
Self-talk is for managing the ordinary discomfort of hard effort, not for overriding warning signs. Chest pain or pressure, unusual breathlessness, palpitations, dizziness, confusion or sharp, localised pain are reasons to stop and get help, whatever your cue words say. TriForward's "When to Pull the Plug: Making the DNF Decision Mid-Race" covers race-day red flags.
In the heat trial, self-talk let cyclists ride on to a higher core temperature before stopping. Inference: in hot races, a mental skill that delays stopping should be paired with sensible pacing, cooling and attention to heat-illness symptoms, not used to push past them.
If your inner voice is persistently harsh, self-critical or hopeless away from training as well as during it, that is worth talking to your GP about rather than trying to fix with cue words. In the UK, Samaritans are available on 116 123.
The evidence comes from small lab trials, mostly in young men cycling, and one ultramarathon trial that found no performance effect. Treat self-talk as a low-cost tool to practise, not a guaranteed gain.
Full Distance
The complete research and analysis.
Every triathlete has an inner voice that pipes up when a session or race gets hard. Sometimes it's helpful ("settle, you've done this before"), sometimes it isn't ("you're going to blow up, you always do"). Sport psychologists call this self-talk, and it's one of the few mental skills with a reasonable body of experimental evidence behind it, including a handful of trials in endurance exercise.
This guide covers what self-talk is, what the meta-analyses and endurance trials actually found, why practice seems to matter more than the exact words, where the evidence falls short, and how to build a small set of phrases for the bad patches in a long race. It's written for age-group triathletes, so it's worth saying early that none of the trials involved triathletes, and the one trial in a real race found no performance benefit. The honest story is that self-talk is cheap, low-risk and probably helpful, not a guaranteed few minutes off your finish time.
What self-talk is
Self-talk is what you say to yourself, out loud or silently. Researchers usually split it in two ways.
- By content. Instructional self-talk directs attention to technique or tactics ("long strokes", "relax the shoulders", "quick feet off the bike"). Motivational self-talk targets effort, confidence and mood ("keep going", "you're strong", "push through this").
- By valence. Positive self-talk encourages, negative self-talk criticises or predicts failure.
There's also a distinction between the self-talk that happens to you, the spontaneous thoughts that pop up when you're suffering, and strategic self-talk, the phrases you plan and practise in advance. Almost all the experimental evidence is about strategic self-talk: athletes are taught a set of phrases and asked to use them, and their performance is compared with a control group or condition.
What the meta-analyses say
Hatzigeorgiadis 2011: a moderate overall effect
The most cited synthesis is a 2011 meta-analysis by Hatzigeorgiadis and colleagues in Perspectives on Psychological Science. It pooled 32 studies yielding 62 effect sizes on self-talk interventions and task performance in sport.
- Overall effect: a positive, moderate effect size of 0.48.
- Task type: self-talk was more effective for tasks with relatively fine motor demands (such as precision skills) than for gross motor tasks (such as strength or endurance).
- Familiarity: it was more effective for novel tasks than for well-learned ones.
- Type of self-talk: instructional self-talk worked better than motivational self-talk for fine tasks.
- Training: interventions that included self-talk training were more effective than those that didn't.
For a triathlete, two of these moderators cut against you. Swimming, cycling and running are gross motor tasks, and most experienced athletes have done them thousands of times. So the overall 0.48 is probably an overestimate of what to expect in endurance. The training finding cuts the other way: it suggests that practising your phrases is part of what makes self-talk work.
Tod 2011: negative self-talk isn't the enemy you think
A systematic review by Tod, Hardy and Oliver in the Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology in the same year analysed 47 studies. It found beneficial effects for positive, instructional and motivational self-talk, and two results that challenge popular advice:
- Negative self-talk did not consistently impede performance.
- The evidence that instructional and motivational self-talk suit different tasks was inconsistent.
The authors specifically recommended against thought-stopping techniques, where you try to block or banish negative thoughts. That matters for race day. Inference: aiming never to have a negative thought in the last 10 km of an Ironman marathon is unrealistic, and the review suggests you don't need to. Answering the thought is a more achievable aim than eliminating it.
McCormick 2015: endurance-specific support
A 2015 systematic review in Sports Medicine by McCormick, Meijen and Marcora looked only at experimental studies of psychological interventions with whole-body endurance performance as the outcome, in athletes or physically active healthy adults. It found consistent support for imagery, self-talk and goal setting, and noted that interventions that changed perception of effort consistently changed endurance performance. It also flagged weaknesses in the research: few studies in real competition, and few with a placebo or alternative-treatment control.
The endurance trials
Blanchfield 2014: time to exhaustion
The trial that put self-talk on the endurance map was published by Blanchfield and colleagues in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise in 2014.
- Who: 24 participants, mean age 24.6 years, with a mean VO2max of 52.3 ml/kg/min (fit, but not elite). The sex split isn't reported in the abstract.
- Design: randomised, between-group, pre-test and post-test. Both groups did a constant-load cycling test to exhaustion at 80% of peak power output, then repeated it after two weeks. The self-talk group spent those two weeks learning and practising motivational self-talk. The control group didn't.
- Result: in the self-talk group, time to exhaustion rose from 637 to 750 seconds. The control group didn't improve significantly.
- Perception of effort: self-talk significantly reduced rating of perceived exertion (RPE) during the test.
Inference: 637 to 750 seconds is an increase of about 18%. That sounds large, but time-to-exhaustion tests are known to change by much bigger percentages than time trials for the same underlying improvement, so it doesn't mean 18% faster racing.
Wallace 2017: self-talk in the heat
Wallace and colleagues, also in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise (2017), tested a two-week motivational self-talk intervention written specifically around coping with heat.
- Who: 18 trained cyclists, 14 men and 4 women, randomised to self-talk (9) or control (9).
- Protocol: 30 minutes at 60% of peak power output in 35 °C and 50% humidity, a rest, then a time-to-exhaustion test at 80% of peak power output.
- Result: in the self-talk group, time to exhaustion rose from 487 to 679 seconds. In the control group it went from 531 to 510 seconds.
- Core temperature: the self-talk group stopped at a higher rectal temperature after the intervention (38.8 °C vs 38.5 °C before). The control group's didn't change.
- Cognition: speed and accuracy on an executive-function test also improved with self-talk.
That higher stopping temperature is the interesting and slightly uncomfortable part. Self-talk didn't make the cyclists cooler. It let them tolerate more heat before stopping. In a lab with supervision that's fine. In a hot race it's a reason to pair self-talk with sensible pacing and cooling, not to use it to override heat warning signs (see TriForward's "Humid, Not Just Hot: What a Sticky Race Day Does to Pacing and Cooling").
Barwood 2015: a 10 km time trial
Time-to-exhaustion tests aren't races. Barwood and colleagues, in the International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance (2015), used 10 km cycling time trials instead.
- Who: 14 men, matched into two groups of 7 on their earlier time-trial performance.
- Design: four time trials. After the third, one group was taught motivational self-talk and the other neutral self-talk, a better control than doing nothing.
- Before the intervention: completion times were similar (1,120 vs 1,150 seconds).
- After: the motivational group rode 1,078 seconds. The neutral group rode 1,165 seconds, essentially unchanged.
- How: the motivational group produced higher power in the second half of the trial (kilometres 6 to 10), and RPE was unchanged.
- Uncertainty: the confidence interval suggested the likely true improvement lay between 13 and 71 seconds.
Inference: 42 seconds off a roughly 19-minute effort is about 4%, but with 7 people per group and a range of 13 to 71 seconds, the precise size is very uncertain. The pattern, the same effort feeling producing more power late in the effort, is the useful part.
Hardy 2019: "you" beats "I"
A smaller, more specific question came from Hardy, Thomas and Blanchfield in the Journal of Sports Sciences (2019). In a randomised, counterbalanced crossover, 16 physically active men (mean age 22) rode 10 km time trials using either first-person self-talk ("I can do this") or second-person self-talk ("you can do this").
- Second-person self-talk produced a significantly faster time trial, with higher power throughout.
- RPE was similar between conditions.
The authors linked this to self-distancing: talking to yourself as you'd talk to someone else may make it easier to regulate emotion and effort. It's one study in 16 young men, so treat it as a cheap thing to try rather than a rule.
Where it didn't work: the ultramarathon trial
The most race-like test is also the least flattering. McCormick, Meijen and Marcora published a randomised controlled trial in The Sport Psychologist (2018) of 29 ultramarathon runners preparing for a 60-mile overnight race. One group learned motivational self-talk; the other was an alternative-treatment control group.
- Self-talk did not improve performance.
- It didn't change pre-race self-efficacy or perceived control.
- But most participants found it helpful, and were still using it six months later, mainly in endurance events, to cope with exertion and other stressors such as blisters and bad conditions.
There are good reasons why a race trial might find nothing even if self-talk helps: finishing times in a 60-mile overnight race vary hugely with weather, navigation, stomach problems and sleep, so a small benefit is easily lost in the noise. But it's the closest trial to what triathletes actually do, and it didn't show a performance effect. That belongs in the story, not in a footnote.
Who was studied
The populations are a real limitation:
- Small samples: 14 to 29 people per trial.
- Mostly men: Barwood and Hardy were all male; Wallace had 4 women out of 18; Blanchfield's split isn't given in the abstract.
- Mostly young: mean ages in the low to mid-twenties in the lab trials.
- Mostly cycling in a lab: constant-load tests and 10 km time trials of 8 to 20 minutes, not three-sport races of 1 to 17 hours.
- No triathletes.
Inference: the direction of effect is consistent across the cycling trials, and the mechanism (changing how hard effort feels) is plausible for any endurance event. Whether the size of effect carries over to a 40-year-old woman in the second half of a 70.3 run isn't known.
How self-talk might work
The lab trials were designed around the psychobiological model of endurance, which says that you stop or slow down when perceived effort reaches the maximum you're willing to tolerate. Anything that lowers perceived effort, or raises your willingness to tolerate it, should extend performance. In Blanchfield's trial, self-talk lowered RPE. In Barwood's and Hardy's, RPE stayed the same while power went up, which is a similar thing seen from the other side: more output for the same perceived effort.
Other proposed routes include directing attention (instructional cues about form), managing anxiety and boosting confidence. TriForward's "Where to Put Your Attention: Internal vs External Focus in a Long Race" covers the attentional side in more detail.
Building your own self-talk
The trials share a common method, and it's worth copying the method rather than borrowing someone else's words. Inference: this is a practical adaptation for triathletes, not a tested programme.
- Notice your usual negative thoughts. In the next few hard sessions, note what your inner voice says when it gets tough. Common ones: "I can't hold this", "everyone's passing me", "my legs are gone", "I'll never make the cut-off".
- Write a counter for each. Short, believable and in your own words. "I can't hold this" might become "you've held this before, one more minute". Avoid phrases you don't believe, and avoid absolutes.
- Mix motivational and instructional cues. Motivational for effort and mood ("keep pushing", "you're doing well"), instructional for form ("tall and relaxed", "light feet", "smooth pedal stroke"). Technique cues may be especially useful when fatigue is degrading form in the run.
- Try the second person. Talking to yourself as "you" is cheap to try, based on one small trial.
- Practise in hard sessions. The trials used about two weeks of practice, and the meta-analysis found trained self-talk worked better. Use your phrases in threshold intervals, long brick runs and the last part of long rides.
- Keep the list short. Three to five phrases you can recall when tired beat a long list you can't.
- Pair phrases with moments. Many athletes link particular cues to particular points: the swim start, the first climb, T2, each aid station.
A triathlon scenario
The following example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 38-year-old age-grouper training for her first full-distance race has a recurring problem: around 20 km into the marathon, her inner voice starts telling her she's going to have to walk, and she usually does.
Over eight weeks of build training, she:
- Writes down the thoughts that appear in the last 30 minutes of her long brick runs: "this is too far", "you'll have to walk".
- Writes counters: "you only need to reach the next aid station", "short steps, keep the rhythm", "you've trained for this feeling".
- Uses them in every long brick run and in the final interval of hard sessions, saying them under her breath.
- Plans a cue for each aid station: walk the station as planned, take fuel, then "you, rhythm, go" as she leaves.
On race day the negative thoughts still appear, as the Tod review would predict. The difference is that she has a practised reply ready. Whether that changes her time is uncertain; the ultramarathon trial suggests the benefit may be smaller in a long race than in a lab. But it's a low-cost tool, and it fits naturally with breaking the run into sections, as described in TriForward's "Breaking the Race Down: Chunking an Ironman Into Pieces You Can Manage".
Common mistakes
- Using generic slogans. "No pain, no gain" from a poster rarely answers the specific thought you have at kilometre 30.
- Not practising. Trying self-talk for the first time on race day ignores the finding that trained self-talk works better.
- Trying to banish negative thoughts. The review evidence suggests negative thoughts don't necessarily harm performance, and thought-stopping isn't recommended.
- Using phrases you don't believe. "You feel amazing" when you clearly don't can backfire. Realistic phrases ("this is hard and you can still do it") are easier to accept.
- Talking yourself past warning signs. Self-talk is for the ordinary discomfort of hard effort, not chest pain, confusion or injury pain. TriForward's "When to Pull the Plug" covers the difference.
- Expecting it to replace pacing. Self-talk won't rescue a bike ridden far too hard. TriForward's "Racing by Feel vs. Racing by Numbers" covers pacing itself.
What we don't know
- Whether self-talk improves triathlon performance. No trial has tested it in triathletes or in a multisport race.
- Effects in long races. The one race trial, in ultramarathon runners, found no performance benefit. Lab efforts lasted 8 to 20 minutes.
- Effects in women and older athletes. The trials are mostly in young men.
- Long-term use. Whether the effect fades, grows or holds after months of use isn't clear, though runners in the ultramarathon trial kept using it.
- Placebo and expectation. It's hard to blind people to a self-talk intervention, so some of the effect may come from expecting to improve. The neutral-self-talk control in Barwood's trial helps, but it was small.
- Best content. Whether motivational or instructional self-talk suits endurance better, and whether personalised phrases beat standard ones, hasn't been settled.
References
- Hatzigeorgiadis A, Zourbanos N, Galanis E, Theodorakis Y. Self-talk and sports performance: a meta-analysis. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2011;6(4):348–356. doi:10.1177/1745691611413136
- Tod D, Hardy J, Oliver E. Effects of self-talk: a systematic review. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2011;33(5):666–687. doi:10.1123/jsep.33.5.666
- McCormick A, Meijen C, Marcora S. Psychological determinants of whole-body endurance performance. Sports Medicine, 2015;45(7):997–1015. doi:10.1007/s40279-015-0319-6
- Blanchfield AW, Hardy J, De Morree HM, Staiano W, Marcora SM. Talking yourself out of exhaustion: the effects of self-talk on endurance performance. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2014;46(5):998–1007. doi:10.1249/MSS.0000000000000184
- Wallace PJ, McKinlay BJ, Coletta NA, Vlaar JI, Taber MJ, Wilson PM, Cheung SS. Effects of motivational self-talk on endurance and cognitive performance in the heat. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2017;49(1):191–199. doi:10.1249/MSS.0000000000001087
- Barwood MJ, Corbett J, Wagstaff CR, McVeigh D, Thelwell RC. Improvement of 10-km time-trial cycling with motivational self-talk compared with neutral self-talk. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 2015;10(2):166–171. doi:10.1123/ijspp.2014-0059
- Hardy J, Thomas AV, Blanchfield AW. To me, to you: how you say things matters for endurance performance. Journal of Sports Sciences, 2019;37(18):2122–2130. doi:10.1080/02640414.2019.1622240
- McCormick A, Meijen C, Marcora S. Effects of a motivational self-talk intervention for endurance athletes completing an ultramarathon. The Sport Psychologist, 2018;32(1):42–50. doi:10.1123/tsp.2017-0018
Frequently asked questions
Does positive self-talk actually improve endurance?
In small lab trials, practised motivational self-talk extended cycling time to exhaustion, from 637 to 750 seconds in one study of 24 people, and improved a 10 km time trial in 14 men. A meta-analysis of 32 studies found a moderate overall benefit. A trial in 29 ultramarathon runners found no performance effect, so the gains aren't guaranteed in races.
What should I say to myself in a race?
Short, personal, motivational phrases that answer the thought you usually have when it gets hard, such as "keep pushing" or "you're doing well", practised in training. Instructional cues about technique ("long and relaxed", "quick feet") can help too. One study found that addressing yourself as "you" was faster than "I".
Is negative self-talk bad for performance?
Less than you might think. A systematic review of 47 studies found negative self-talk didn't consistently impede performance, and advised against trying to stop thoughts outright. Noticing a negative thought and answering it with a prepared phrase is a more realistic aim.
How long does it take to learn self-talk?
The cycling trials used about two weeks of practice, with athletes writing their own phrases and using them in training. The meta-analysis found self-talk worked better when it had been trained, so practise it in hard sessions before race day.
The evidence behind this guide
1 graded principle, 8 sources. Open one to see the sources.
Practised motivational self-talk extended endurance and time-trial performance in small lab cycling trials, but the one race-based trial found no performance benefitLimited evidence8 sources
In practice: Write a few short, believable phrases that answer your usual negative thoughts, mix motivational and technique cues, consider addressing yourself as 'you', and practise them in hard sessions before racing. Expect a modest or uncertain race-day effect: this is extrapolated from short lab cycling tests, mostly in young men, and never a reason to push past warning signs such as chest pain, confusion or heat-illness symptoms.
32 studies, 62 effect sizes: moderate positive effect of self-talk interventions on sport task performance (ES 0.48). Larger for fine than gross motor tasks and for novel than well-learned tasks; instructional self-talk beat motivational for fine tasks; interventions that included self-talk training were more effective. Mostly non-endurance tasks, so the pooled effect probably overstates what to expect in endurance.
47 studies: positive, instructional and motivational self-talk benefited performance; negative self-talk did not impede performance; evidence that instructional and motivational self-talk suit different tasks was inconsistent; cognitive and behavioural mediators most consistent. Recommends avoiding thought-stopping techniques. Narrative synthesis, not pooled.
Systematic review of psychological manipulations with whole-body endurance performance as the outcome: consistent support for imagery, self-talk and goal setting; mental fatigue undermines endurance performance; verbal encouragement and head-to-head competition can help; interventions that changed perception of effort consistently changed endurance performance. Few studies in real competition or with placebo or alternative-treatment controls.
Randomised between-group pre/post design. After a 2-week motivational self-talk intervention, constant-load cycling time to exhaustion at 80% of peak power rose from 637 ± 210 to 750 ± 295 s (about 18%, TriForward's arithmetic) and RPE was significantly reduced; the control group did not improve. Small sample, lab time-to-exhaustion test, not a race.
2-week heat-specific motivational self-talk training. After 30 min at 60% peak power in 35 °C, 50% RH, time to exhaustion at 80% peak power rose from 487 to 679 s (P = 0.021) with a higher terminal rectal temperature (38.5 to 38.8 °C); control 531 to 510 s, temperature unchanged. Executive-function speed and accuracy also improved. Small, mostly male; self-talk raised heat tolerance rather than lowering heat strain.
Four 10 km cycling time trials. Before the intervention times were similar (1120 vs 1150 s); after it the motivational group rode 1078 s and the neutral group 1165 s, with higher power and VO2 in km 6-10 and unchanged RPE. 95% CI of the likely true improvement 13-71 s. Very small groups, men only, matched rather than randomised allocation.
Second-person self-talk ('you') produced a significantly faster 10 km cycling time trial than first-person self-talk ('I') (p = .014), with greater power output (p = .03) and similar RPE (p = .75). Single small study in young men.
Randomised controlled trial around a 60-mile overnight ultramarathon: learning motivational self-talk did not affect pre-event self-efficacy, perceived control or performance. Most participants found it helpful and were still using it six months later, to cope with exertion, blisters and adverse conditions. The only race-based trial here, and it found no performance effect.
Get The Forward
Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.
