Coaches and athletes broadly agree on session effort, but athletes consistently rate sessions planned as easy harder than coaches intend
Interpretation
A meta-analysis of 27 studies found no overall coach-athlete difference in RPE (SMD 0.19) or session RPE (SMD 0.05) but a consistent gap on easy sessions (RPE SMD -0.44; session RPE SMD -0.54) (Inoue 2022). Coach-athlete correlations pool at r = 0.62-0.64 (Paul 2021, 19 articles). The easy-day pattern appears in 33 young soccer players over 2446 sessions, where hard days were also felt as easier (Brink 2014), in 12 well-trained swimmers, 6 M and 6 F (Wallace 2009), and in 14 male cyclists (easy median 3.0 vs 2.0 planned; Inoue 2022). Junior speed skaters did less than intended (Otter 2022). Subjective ratings track training load better than objective markers (Saw 2016). Graded moderate: consistent direction across a meta-analysis and several studies, but mostly team sports and young athletes; no age-group triathletes, and the one age-group triathlon coaching pilot (4 coaches, 10 athletes) found load reports were rarely acted on (Procida 2024). No study tests whether closing the gap improves performance or injury.
Practical implication
Rate every session honestly on a 0-10 scale, compare it with your coach's intended effort, slow easy sessions that feel harder than planned, and report missed or shortened sessions. Agree with your coach how the ratings will be used. Extrapolated from team sports, swimmers and cyclists, not tested in age-group triathletes.
Sources
10 sources, independently verified.
Two-part validation of the session RPE method (session rating x duration) against a heart-rate method in steady and interval cycling and in basketball practice. Relationships were highly consistent, with higher absolute scores from session RPE; regression lines from the two parts nearly overlapped, suggesting broad applicability. Sample size, sex and training status not given in the abstract.
27 studies, athletes of any sex, age or level. No overall coach-athlete difference for RPE (SMD 0.19) or session RPE (SMD 0.05). Athletes rated coach-planned easy sessions harder: RPE SMD -0.44 (small), session RPE SMD -0.54 (moderate). No differences for moderate or hard sessions. Mostly team sports.
19 articles. Pooled correlation between coach rating of intended exertion and athlete RPE r = 0.62 (95% CI 0.5 to 0.7; 11 studies) and between coach-observed exertion and athlete RPE r = 0.64 (7 studies): a moderate to high association influenced by many factors.
Full season, 2446 sessions. Players perceived training as harder than coaches intended; coach-player correlations weak (intensity r = 0.24, duration 0.49, load 0.41). On coach-intended easy and intermediate days players reported higher intensity and load; on hard days lower intensity, duration and load. First-year U17 players found sessions harder.
Two 4-week mesocycles, 977 sessions. Coach-intended vs player-perceived exertion r = 0.58; coach-observed vs perceived r = 0.64. Coaches based intended and observed exertion on expected and actual on-field load and players' intermittent endurance capacity.
20 swim sessions per swimmer. Session RPE correlated with heart-rate methods (r = 0.55-0.94) and distance (r = 0.37-0.81). Coach RPE was lower than athlete RPE for low-intensity sessions and higher than athlete RPE for high-intensity sessions.
No coach-cyclist differences in average RPE, duration or session RPE; correlations r = 0.73 (RPE), 0.95 (duration), 0.87 (session RPE). Sessions designed to be easy were perceived harder by cyclists: median 3.0 vs 2.0 planned (P = 0.013).
4-week preparatory period, 438 intended and 378 executed sessions (14 skaters with full data). Perceived duration 45:16 h vs 52:37 h intended (fewer sessions done); perceived load lower than intended for skating and strength sessions; large individual variation. Skaters who approached or exceeded intended training reported increases in success, physical recovery, self-regulation and accomplishment (r about 0.57-0.60).
10-week competition-season pilot. Coaches received weekly training-load reports. Weekly acute load spikes over 10% occurred in 83% (swim), 74% (bike) and 87% (run) of weeks; coaches adjusted the next week's load after 25% of reports, and only 5%, 33% and 9% of adjusted loads avoided spikes. 1.5% of training was lost to injury, mostly after a running load spike over 30%. Very small, no self-coached comparison group.
Subjective and objective measures generally did not correlate; subjective measures reflected acute and chronic training load with greater sensitivity and consistency. Subjective well-being was impaired by acute load increases and chronic training and improved with an acute decrease in load. Mixed sports and levels.