When Your Coach's "Easy" Isn't Your Easy: Intended vs Perceived Training Load
Coaches and athletes broadly agree on how hard training is, except on easy days, which athletes rate harder than planned. What session-RPE studies show, why it matters, and how honest feedback closes the gap.
Sprint Summary
The short version — read this if you're short on time.
Coaches and athletes mostly agree on how hard training is, but not on easy days. A 2022 meta-analysis of 27 studies, using session ratings of perceived exertion (RPE), found no overall difference between the effort coaches intended and the effort athletes reported. For sessions the coach planned as easy, though, athletes consistently rated them harder. In one study of 33 young elite soccer players, hard days were also felt as easier than planned, so the week flattened into the middle. In 14 trained male cyclists, sessions planned at 2 out of 10 were rated 3.
That matters because the easy days are what make the hard days possible. If your "easy" is drifting into moderate, the plan your coach thinks you're doing isn't the one you are doing. The fix is simple and cheap: rate every session honestly on a 0 to 10 scale, share it, and treat easy sessions that feel hard as information, not weakness. Most of the evidence is from team sports, swimmers and cyclists rather than age-group triathletes, so the size of the gap for you is individual.
If easy sessions feel persistently harder than they should, alongside poor sleep, low mood, frequent illness or falling performance, that can be a sign of overreaching, under-fuelling or illness. Tell your coach and see your GP if it lasts more than a couple of weeks. TriForward's "Under-Fuelled, Not Undertrained" covers low energy availability.
Session RPE measures how hard training felt. It doesn't detect injury. Pain that changes how you move, or that's worse each session, needs a physiotherapist or doctor, whatever the numbers say.
Unusual breathlessness, chest pain, palpitations or dizziness during an easy session are not a load-monitoring issue. Stop and get medical advice promptly.
Most of this evidence comes from team sports, swimmers, cyclists and young athletes, not age-group triathletes. The direction of the easy-day gap is consistent, but how big it is for you is individual.
Full Distance
The complete research and analysis.
Your plan says Tuesday is an easy 45-minute run. You finish it, tick it off, and the app shows green. But if someone had asked how hard it felt, the honest answer might have been "harder than easy should be". You'd had a long day, slept badly, and the route has a hill you can't avoid. Your coach, looking at the week, sees an easy run. You lived a moderate one.
This gap between what a coach intends and what an athlete experiences has been studied for over 20 years, mostly in team sports. The findings are consistent enough to be useful and simple enough to act on. This article covers how training load is measured with session ratings of perceived exertion, what studies comparing coaches and athletes show, why easy days are where the gap appears, and what you and your coach can do about it.
How perceived training load is measured
The standard tool is session RPE. After a session, you rate how hard the whole session felt on a 0 to 10 scale, where 0 is rest and 10 is maximal. Multiply that number by the session's duration in minutes and you get a training load in arbitrary units.
In 2001, Carl Foster and colleagues published the method's validation in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. In a two-part design, people did steady and interval cycling or practised basketball, and their session RPE scores were compared with a heart-rate-based method:
- In cycling, the relationship between the two methods was highly consistent, though session RPE gave higher absolute scores.
- In basketball, the relationship was also consistent, again with higher scores from session RPE.
- The regression lines from the two parts were nearly overlapping, even with different participants, suggesting it works across different types of exercise.
The abstract doesn't give sample sizes, sex split or training status. The method has since been used across many sports. It's attractive for triathletes because one number works for swimming, cycling, running and strength sessions, including ones where heart rate or power isn't meaningful.
Inference: a 60-minute easy ride rated 3 scores 180 units; a 60-minute threshold session rated 7 scores 420. That's the arithmetic. What the coach-athlete research adds is a comparison: the coach can rate how hard they intended the session to be before it happens, and compare it with what you report afterwards.
What the studies show
The big picture: two meta-analyses
A 2022 systematic review and meta-analysis by Inoue and colleagues in Sports Medicine - Open pooled 27 studies comparing the load athletes perceived with the load coaches planned, intended or observed. Studies could include athletes of any sex, age or level.
- Overall RPE: no significant difference between coaches and athletes (standardised mean difference 0.19).
- Overall session RPE: no significant difference (SMD 0.05).
- Easy sessions: a significant difference. Athletes rated sessions planned as easy harder than coaches intended, for both RPE (SMD -0.44, a small effect) and session RPE (SMD -0.54, a moderate effect).
- Moderate and hard sessions: no significant differences.
The authors concluded that coaches and athletes broadly agree and that RPE tools are adequate for monitoring, with the exception of easy sessions.
A second meta-analysis, by Paul and colleagues in 2021 in the same journal, looked at the correlation between coach and athlete ratings across 19 articles:
- Coach-intended effort vs athlete RPE: r = 0.62 from 11 studies.
- Coach-observed effort vs athlete RPE: r = 0.64 from 7 studies.
They described this as a moderate to high association, influenced by many factors. A correlation around 0.6 means coach and athlete ratings move together, but there's plenty of room for individual sessions to differ.
Young soccer players: a flattened week
The best-known individual study is by Brink and colleagues in the International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance in 2014. They followed 33 young elite soccer players from under-19 and under-17 squads for a full competitive season, comparing 2,446 sessions with their coaches' planned periodisation.
- Players perceived training as significantly harder overall than coaches intended.
- Correlations were weak: r = 0.24 for intensity, 0.49 for duration and 0.41 for load.
- On coach-intended easy and intermediate days, players reported higher intensity and load.
- On coach-intended hard days, players reported lower intensity, duration and load.
- First-year under-17 players found sessions harder than second-year players.
So the hard days weren't as hard as planned and the easy days weren't as easy. The week flattened towards the middle, which is the pattern endurance coaches try hardest to avoid. These were young male team-sport athletes, so the absolute numbers don't transfer to triathletes, but the pattern is a useful warning.
A 2017 follow-up by Brink and colleagues in the same journal monitored 31 elite young soccer players over 977 sessions and found correlations of r = 0.58 between coach-intended and player-perceived exertion. The coaches based their ratings on what they expected the players to do and what they saw them do on the field.
Swimmers: the same pattern in an endurance sport
Closer to triathlon, Wallace, Slattery and Coutts studied 12 well-trained swimmers (6 men, 6 women, average age 22.3) over 20 training sessions in a 2009 paper in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research.
- Session RPE correlated with heart-rate methods (r = 0.55 to 0.94) and with distance (r = 0.37 to 0.81) for every swimmer.
- Coach RPE was lower than athlete RPE for low-intensity sessions, and higher than athlete RPE for high-intensity sessions.
That's the same flattening seen in soccer, in a small sample of swimmers with an even sex split.
Cyclists: easy planned at 2, felt at 3
A 2022 study by Inoue and colleagues in the European Journal of Sport Science compared the plans of 5 coaches with the reports of 14 male road and mountain-bike cyclists.
- Average RPE, duration and session RPE didn't differ between coaches and cyclists.
- Correlations were large: r = 0.73 for RPE, 0.95 for duration and 0.87 for session RPE.
- But sessions designed to be easy were rated harder by cyclists: a median of 3.0 compared with 2.0 planned.
Inference: on a 0 to 10 scale, the difference between 2 and 3 is the difference between genuinely easy and the bottom of moderate. Across several easy sessions a week, that adds up.
Junior speed skaters: less than planned
Not every mismatch goes the same way. In a 2022 study by Otter and colleagues in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2 coaches and 23 junior speed skaters were followed over a four-week preparation period, with full data from 14 skaters.
- Skaters did less than intended: 45 hours 16 minutes of training against 52 hours 37 minutes planned, partly because they completed fewer sessions.
- Perceived load was lower than intended for both skating and strength sessions.
- Individual variation was large.
- Skaters who came close to or exceeded the coach's intentions reported increases in perceived success, physical recovery and self-regulation.
Inference: the gap isn't only about easy sessions being too hard. Missed or shortened sessions also mean the coach's picture of your training is wrong.
What about triathlon?
There's very little direct evidence. The most relevant study is a 2024 pilot by Procida and colleagues in Sports. Over 10 weeks, 4 male age-group triathlon coaches were sent weekly reports of training load for their 10 athletes (6 women, 4 men, average age 38), then asked whether they used the information to plan the following week.
- Weekly load fluctuations above 10% were common: 83% of weeks for swimming, 74% for cycling and 87% for running.
- Coaches adjusted loads in response to 25% of the reports.
- Few adjustments kept fluctuations under 10%: 5% for swimming, 33% for cycling and 9% for running.
- Only 1.5% of training was lost to injury, mostly after a large running load spike of over 30%.
This study used training stress scores rather than session RPE, and it's tiny. But it suggests that even when age-group triathlon coaches have load data, they don't always use it. Inference: your session ratings are only useful if someone looks at them, so make sure you and your coach agree how they'll be used.
Why subjective ratings are worth the effort
It's tempting to think heart rate, power and pace make RPE redundant. A 2016 systematic review by Saw, Main and Gastin in the British Journal of Sports Medicine suggests otherwise. Across 56 studies that measured both subjective and objective markers of athlete wellbeing:
- Subjective and objective measures generally didn't correlate.
- Subjective measures responded to acute and chronic training load with better sensitivity and consistency than objective measures.
- Subjective wellbeing worsened with acute increases in load and with chronic training, and improved with acute decreases.
Inference: how a session felt, and how you feel generally, is not a soft extra. It's one of the more sensitive signals you have. TriForward's "Reading the Trend, Not the Number" covers heart rate variability, which works best alongside subjective ratings rather than instead of them.
Why easy days drift
None of the studies fully explains the gap, but a few plausible reasons stand out. These are inference, not findings:
- Residual fatigue. Coaches rate the session in isolation; you do it with yesterday's intervals still in your legs.
- Life stress and sleep. Age-groupers bring work, family and short nights to every session.
- Conditions. Heat, wind, hills and the turbo all change how a given pace or power feels. TriForward's "Why Your Indoor Watts Are Lower: Heat, Fans and the Smart Trainer" covers indoor heat.
- Company. An easy ride with a faster group rarely stays easy.
- Targets that are too high. If your zones come from an old or optimistic test, "easy" may not be easy. TriForward's "Finding Zone 2: Heart Rate, Lactate, Talk Test or Breathing Threshold?" covers setting them.
- Pride. Rating an easy session as 4 can feel like admitting weakness, so some athletes round down.
Practical application
- Rate every session. Once you've cooled down, rate the whole session from 0 to 10, not just the last effort. Be honest, especially on easy days.
- Ask your coach for their intended rating. Many coaching platforms let coaches add a target RPE. If yours doesn't, ask what "easy" should feel like as a number.
- Look for patterns, not single sessions. One hard-feeling easy run means little. Three in a week is worth a conversation.
- Slow down when easy feels hard. Reduce pace or power until the effort matches the plan, and note that you did.
- Report missed and shortened sessions. As the speed-skating study showed, doing less than planned also distorts the picture.
- Agree what happens with the information. The triathlon pilot found coaches often didn't act on load reports.
- Add a quick wellbeing check. Sleep, mood, soreness and stress, rated briefly each day, add context.
TriForward's "What to Expect From a Coach, and What a Coach Should Expect From You" covers why honest feedback is part of the athlete's side of the relationship. If you're self-coached, the same method works: write down your intended RPE before each session and compare.
A triathlon scenario
The following example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 39-year-old experienced triathlete is in the base phase for a long-distance race. His coach's plan has four easy sessions a week, each intended at about 2 or 3 out of 10. He rates his sessions for a fortnight and notices that his Tuesday and Thursday easy runs, done after work on a hilly route, come in at 4 or 5. His Saturday long ride with the club is a 5. His Wednesday threshold session, meanwhile, rates only 6, and he's been missing the last interval.
His coach spots the pattern and suggests:
- Moving one easy run to a flat route, with a heart-rate cap.
- Riding the first half of the club ride with the group, then dropping back to his own pace.
- Keeping the threshold session, now that the easy days are genuinely easy.
After three weeks, his easy sessions rate 2 or 3 and the threshold session rates 7 with all intervals completed. The intended polarised week has returned. TriForward's "Polarised, Pyramidal or Threshold: How to Spread Your Winter Intensity" covers why that distribution matters.
Common mistakes
- Not rating sessions at all, relying on device data alone.
- Rating to please the coach, rounding easy sessions down.
- Rating only the last interval rather than the whole session.
- Treating a single hard-feeling session as a crisis, rather than looking at the trend.
- Silently changing sessions instead of reporting why.
- Coaches assuming the plan is what happened, without checking.
What we don't know
- The size of the gap in age-group triathletes. No study has compared coach-intended and athlete-perceived load in triathlon.
- Whether closing the gap improves performance or reduces injury. The studies show the mismatch; none tested an intervention to fix it.
- Women. Most samples are male or don't report the split; the swimming study is the exception.
- Remote coaching. Most studies involve coaches who watch training. Online coaches rely entirely on what you report.
- Multisport effects. Whether a hard bike session makes the next day's easy run feel harder than a coach expects is plausible but untested.
References
- Foster C, Florhaug JA, Franklin J, Gottschall L, Hrovatin LA, Parker S, Doleshal P, Dodge C. A new approach to monitoring exercise training. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2001;15(1):109–115. doi:10.1519/00124278-200102000-00019
- Inoue A, Dos Santos Bunn P, do Carmo EC, Lattari E, da Silva EB. Internal training load perceived by athletes and planned by coaches: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine - Open, 2022;8(1):35. doi:10.1186/s40798-022-00420-3
- Paul D, Read P, Farooq A, Jones L. Factors influencing the association between coach and athlete rating of exertion: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine - Open, 2021;7(1):1. doi:10.1186/s40798-020-00287-2
- Brink MS, Frencken WGP, Jordet G, Lemmink KAPM. Coaches' and players' perceptions of training dose: not a perfect match. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 2014;9(3):497–502. doi:10.1123/ijspp.2013-0009
- Brink MS, Kersten AW, Frencken WGP. Understanding the mismatch between coaches' and players' perceptions of exertion. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 2017;12(4):562–568. doi:10.1123/ijspp.2016-0215
- Wallace LK, Slattery KM, Coutts AJ. The ecological validity and application of the session-RPE method for quantifying training loads in swimming. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2009;23(1):33–38. doi:10.1519/JSC.0b013e3181874512
- Inoue A, do Carmo EC, de Souza Terra B, Moraes BR, Lattari E, Borin JP. Comparison of coach-athlete perceptions on internal and external training loads in trained cyclists. European Journal of Sport Science, 2022;22(8):1261–1267. doi:10.1080/17461391.2021.1927198
- Otter RTA, Bakker AC, van der Zwaard S, Toering T, Goudsmit JFA, Stoter IK, de Jong J. Perceived training of junior speed skaters versus the coach's intention: does a mismatch relate to perceived stress and recovery? International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2022;19(18):11221. doi:10.3390/ijerph191811221
- Procida D, Mara J, Mitchell L, Etxebarria N. How do age-group triathlon coaches manage training load? A pilot study. Sports, 2024;12(9):261. doi:10.3390/sports12090261
- Saw AE, Main LC, Gastin PB. Monitoring the athlete training response: subjective self-reported measures trump commonly used objective measures: a systematic review. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2016;50(5):281–291. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2015-094758
Frequently asked questions
Do coaches and athletes agree on how hard training is?
Broadly, yes. A meta-analysis of 27 studies found no overall difference between the effort coaches planned and athletes reported. The exception was easy sessions, which athletes rated harder than coaches intended. Moderate and hard sessions matched more closely.
Why do easy sessions feel harder than planned?
The studies don't fully explain it. Likely reasons include fatigue from previous sessions, life stress, heat, terrain, riding or running with faster people, and coaches basing their estimate on what a session should cost rather than what it does. Inference: for age-groupers, work and sleep probably add to the gap.
What is session RPE?
A simple load measure: after a session, rate how hard the whole session was on a 0 to 10 scale and multiply by its duration in minutes. A 60-minute session rated 3 scores 180 units. It was validated against heart-rate methods in 2001 and is widely used.
Should I just do easy sessions slower?
Often, yes, if they're feeling harder than intended. But tell your coach as well, so they can see the pattern and adjust the week rather than you quietly changing sessions. Honest ratings are what make the plan adaptable.
The evidence behind this guide
1 graded principle, 10 sources. Open one to see the sources.
Coaches and athletes broadly agree on session effort, but athletes consistently rate sessions planned as easy harder than coaches intendModerate evidence10 sources
In practice: Rate every session honestly on a 0-10 scale, compare it with your coach's intended effort, slow easy sessions that feel harder than planned, and report missed or shortened sessions. Agree with your coach how the ratings will be used. Extrapolated from team sports, swimmers and cyclists, not tested in age-group triathletes.
Two-part validation of the session RPE method (session rating x duration) against a heart-rate method in steady and interval cycling and in basketball practice. Relationships were highly consistent, with higher absolute scores from session RPE; regression lines from the two parts nearly overlapped, suggesting broad applicability. Sample size, sex and training status not given in the abstract.
27 studies, athletes of any sex, age or level. No overall coach-athlete difference for RPE (SMD 0.19) or session RPE (SMD 0.05). Athletes rated coach-planned easy sessions harder: RPE SMD -0.44 (small), session RPE SMD -0.54 (moderate). No differences for moderate or hard sessions. Mostly team sports.
19 articles. Pooled correlation between coach rating of intended exertion and athlete RPE r = 0.62 (95% CI 0.5 to 0.7; 11 studies) and between coach-observed exertion and athlete RPE r = 0.64 (7 studies): a moderate to high association influenced by many factors.
Full season, 2446 sessions. Players perceived training as harder than coaches intended; coach-player correlations weak (intensity r = 0.24, duration 0.49, load 0.41). On coach-intended easy and intermediate days players reported higher intensity and load; on hard days lower intensity, duration and load. First-year U17 players found sessions harder.
Two 4-week mesocycles, 977 sessions. Coach-intended vs player-perceived exertion r = 0.58; coach-observed vs perceived r = 0.64. Coaches based intended and observed exertion on expected and actual on-field load and players' intermittent endurance capacity.
20 swim sessions per swimmer. Session RPE correlated with heart-rate methods (r = 0.55-0.94) and distance (r = 0.37-0.81). Coach RPE was lower than athlete RPE for low-intensity sessions and higher than athlete RPE for high-intensity sessions.
No coach-cyclist differences in average RPE, duration or session RPE; correlations r = 0.73 (RPE), 0.95 (duration), 0.87 (session RPE). Sessions designed to be easy were perceived harder by cyclists: median 3.0 vs 2.0 planned (P = 0.013).
4-week preparatory period, 438 intended and 378 executed sessions (14 skaters with full data). Perceived duration 45:16 h vs 52:37 h intended (fewer sessions done); perceived load lower than intended for skating and strength sessions; large individual variation. Skaters who approached or exceeded intended training reported increases in success, physical recovery, self-regulation and accomplishment (r about 0.57-0.60).
10-week competition-season pilot. Coaches received weekly training-load reports. Weekly acute load spikes over 10% occurred in 83% (swim), 74% (bike) and 87% (run) of weeks; coaches adjusted the next week's load after 25% of reports, and only 5%, 33% and 9% of adjusted loads avoided spikes. 1.5% of training was lost to injury, mostly after a running load spike over 30%. Very small, no self-coached comparison group.
Subjective and objective measures generally did not correlate; subjective measures reflected acute and chronic training load with greater sensitivity and consistency. Subjective well-being was impaired by acute load increases and chronic training and improved with an acute decrease in load. Mixed sports and levels.
Get The Forward
Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.
