Racing & StrategyLimited evidenceMental Skills & Race Psychology

Reappraising pre-performance arousal as excitement or readiness gives a small average performance benefit in lab tasks, but its effect on endurance racing is untested

Interpretation

Striking single studies (Brooks 2014, saying 'I am excited'; Jamieson 2010, 60 students, 28 analysed, higher GRE maths) shrank when pooled: 35 RCTs, 5,638 mostly young students, d = 0.23, 0.14 after trim-and-fill, prediction interval -0.18 to 0.65 (Bosshard and Gomez 2024). Challenge states predict better performance than threat states with small effects across 62 studies (Hase 2025). In sport, anxiety relates only modestly and inconsistently to objective performance (48 studies, 3,659 athletes; race-time correlation with cognitive anxiety r = -0.00), while self-confidence relates more consistently (Lochbaum and Arendt 2026). The only endurance test found more power but no time difference in a 16.1 km cycling time trial (Arthur 2019). Graded limited: consistent but small effects, signs of publication bias, almost entirely non-athlete or non-endurance samples, and no triathlon trials.

Practical implication

Expect and normalise pre-race arousal, relabel it with a short phrase practised in training, pair it with evidence of readiness to support confidence, and keep slow breathing for genuine overload. Expect a small effect at most; this is extrapolated from students and short tasks, and never applies to cardiac or panic symptoms.

Sources

7 sources, independently verified.

Peer-reviewed studyRCTIndependently verified
Get excited: reappraising pre-performance anxiety as excitement ↗
Brooks AW · 2014 · Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
Members of the public and students across a survey and several experiments (karaoke, public speaking, maths); per-study sample sizes not verified

Most people believed calming down was the best way to cope with pre-performance anxiety. Across experiments, reappraising anxiety as excitement (saying 'I am excited' or reading 'get excited') rather than trying to calm down raised felt excitement, promoted an opportunity rather than threat mindset, and improved singing, speech and maths performance. Non-athlete samples; per-study sizes not checked against full text.

Peer-reviewed studyRCTIndependently verified
Turning the knots in your stomach into bows: reappraising arousal improves performance on the GRE ↗
Jamieson JP, Mendes WB, Blackstock E, Schmader T · 2010 · Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
60 students (31 M, 29 F) preparing for the GRE; 28 analysed after follow-up

Students told that arousal improves performance scored higher on practice GRE maths than controls (738.57 vs 683.57, d = 0.82), with no verbal difference, and showed a rise in salivary alpha-amylase (sympathetic activity). On the real GRE one to three months later, the reappraisal group again scored higher on maths. Main analyses based on the 28 who returned.

Meta-analysisIndependently verified
Effectiveness of stress arousal reappraisal and stress-is-enhancing mindset interventions on task performance outcomes: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials ↗
Bosshard M, Gomez P · 2024 · Scientific Reports
35 RCTs, 44 effect sizes, 5,638 participants (65.1% female, mean age 22.6), non-clinical, mostly students

Pooled effect on task performance d = 0.23 (95% CI 0.14-0.33); reappraisal-only d = 0.22, combined interventions d = 0.45 (k = 5); public performance tasks d = 0.34 vs written cognitive tasks d = 0.20. Funnel asymmetry; trim-and-fill reduced the effect to d = 0.14; prediction interval -0.18 to 0.65. No endurance tasks; transfer to sport unclear.

Meta-analysisIndependently verified
The effects of challenge and threat states on performance outcomes: an updated review and meta-analysis of recent findings ↗
Hase A, Nietschke M, Kłoskowski M, Szymański K, Moore L, Jamieson JP, Behnke M · 2025 · EXCLI Journal
62 studies published 2017-2024, 7,418 participants across education, sport and other domains

Challenge states (resources judged to meet demands) were associated with better performance than threat states across domains; all pooled effects were small. Risk of bias generally low; only two of five publication-bias methods suggested bias.

Meta-analysisIndependently verified
A meta-analysis of the CSAI-2 and CSAI-2R with objective sport performance from 1985-2026 ↗
Lochbaum M, Arendt F · 2026 · Sports
48 studies, 3,659 athletes, mostly individual sports (24 male-only, 14 mixed, 11 female-only samples), including 416 Ironman triathletes

Better performers had lower cognitive (g = -0.52) and somatic anxiety (g = -0.37) and higher self-confidence (g = 0.59); correlations were smaller (r = -0.18, -0.24, 0.26). All prediction intervals crossed zero. For raw race times, cognitive anxiety r = -0.00 (4 samples, 593 athletes); race time adjusted to the individual r = -0.30 (3 samples, 149). Recommends day-of, repeated, individual measurement.

Peer-reviewed studyRCTIndependently verified
Examining the effect of challenge and threat states on endurance exercise capabilities ↗
Arthur TG, Wilson MR, Moore LJ, Wylie LJ, Vine SJ · 2019 · Psychology of Sport and Exercise
Two lab cycling studies; sample sizes and sex split not available from accessible sources

Study 1: challenge-type cardiovascular reactivity predicted lower perceived exertion in moderate but not severe-intensity cycling. Study 2: after a challenge, threat or neutral manipulation, the challenge group produced more power in a 16.1 km time trial with tempered fatigue perceptions, but completion time did not differ significantly. Abstract read via search-engine extracts only.

Expert consensusIndependently verified
Performance under pressure in sport: a position statement from Exercise and Sports Science Australia (ESSA) ↗
Schweickle MJ, Appaneal RN, Jackman PC, Minahan CL, Moyle GM, Pickering C, Stewart D, Vella SA, Swann C · 2026 · Sports Medicine

Position statement synthesising reviews on performing under pressure. Pressure training had a moderate effect (meta-analysis of 14 studies, 10 in sport); pre-performance routines moderate-to-large effects (33 studies), best suited to self-paced closed skills; imagery moderate effect, larger with more sessions; notes that performance anxiety can be interpreted facilitatively (challenge states) when perceived control and self-efficacy are high. Classes psychological skills training as control-focused and mindfulness as acceptance-focused, advising alignment when combined.