Race Nerves: Why "I'm Excited" May Beat "Calm Down"
A racing heart and a churning stomach before the start are normal. What arousal-reappraisal research says about reframing nerves as readiness, why the effect is smaller than the headlines, and how to use it on race morning.
Sprint Summary
The short version — read this if you're short on time.
Almost every triathlete feels it: a thumping heart, shaky hands and a churning stomach in the minutes before the start. Most people's instinct is to tell themselves to calm down. A line of psychology research suggests another option, called arousal reappraisal: treat the racing heart as a sign your body is getting ready, and tell yourself "I'm excited" instead. In the best-known studies, people who did this before singing, public speaking or maths tests performed better than those who tried to calm down.
The effect is real but small, and almost none of it comes from athletes. A 2024 meta-analysis of 35 studies and 5,638 people, mostly young students, found an average benefit of d = 0.23, which shrank to 0.14 after correcting for likely publication bias. Sport studies suggest how you interpret nerves and how confident you feel matter more than how nervous you are. The practical message: don't fight normal pre-race arousal, relabel it, practise that before race day, and keep calming techniques for when nerves are genuinely too much.
Nerves before a race are normal, but some symptoms aren't nerves. Chest pain or pressure, fainting, a racing or irregular heartbeat that doesn't settle at rest, or breathlessness out of proportion to effort need medical assessment, not reframing. Don't start a race with them.
Reappraisal is for ordinary pre-race arousal. If anxiety is causing panic attacks, stopping you sleeping for days, or making you avoid racing or training altogether, talk to your GP. In the UK you can also call NHS 111, or Samaritans on 116 123 if you're struggling to cope.
Panic in open water is a drowning risk, not just a performance problem. If you feel panic rising in the swim, roll onto your back, raise a hand for help and use the safety craft. TriForward's "Open Water Sighting and Race-Start Anxiety" covers the physiology of the swim start.
The evidence comes mostly from students in lab tasks, not athletes or endurance events, and the average effect is small. Treat reappraisal as a free tool worth trying, not a guaranteed gain.
Full Distance
The complete research and analysis.
The start of a triathlon is a strange place. You've tapered, you're as fit as you'll be all year, and yet your heart is racing, your hands are shaking and you've been to the toilet three times. Many athletes read this as a sign something is wrong. Friends, coaches and every motivational poster tell you to calm down.
There's a line of research that suggests a different approach. Instead of trying to reduce the arousal, you change what you think it means. A racing heart becomes "my body getting ready" rather than "I'm about to fall apart". This guide looks at that research, called arousal reappraisal, along with broader studies of anxiety and performance in sport. It's honest about the limits: the headline studies were done with students singing karaoke and sitting maths tests, the average effect is small, and there are almost no trials in endurance athletes.
TriForward's "Open Water Sighting and Race-Start Anxiety: Why It's a Physiology Problem, Not Just a Mental Game" covers the physical side of the mass swim start. This guide is about the nerves in general: the hours before, the start pen, and what you tell yourself about them.
What race nerves are
Before an important event, your sympathetic nervous system ramps up. Heart rate and breathing rise, adrenaline and noradrenaline increase, blood is redirected to muscles, and digestion slows. That's why your stomach churns. Sport psychologists usually separate this into:
- Somatic anxiety: the physical side, such as a pounding heart, tense muscles and butterflies.
- Cognitive anxiety: the worry, such as "what if I have a bad swim?" or "I'm not ready".
- Self-confidence: how sure you feel that you can cope with what's coming.
The key idea in modern research is that the physical state of anxiety and the physical state of excitement are very similar. What differs is how you interpret it.
The "get excited" studies
Brooks 2014
The best-known study is a 2014 paper by Alison Wood Brooks in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. It started with a simple observation: an overwhelming majority of people surveyed believed that trying to calm down was the best way to cope with pre-performance anxiety.
Across several experiments involving karaoke singing, public speaking and maths performance, Brooks compared people who reappraised their anxiety as excitement with people who tried to calm down. Those who reappraised:
- felt more excited,
- adopted an opportunity mindset rather than a threat mindset,
- and performed better.
The manipulations were tiny: saying "I am excited" out loud, or reading a short message telling them to get excited. The argument was that calming down is hard when your body is already highly aroused, but relabelling a high-arousal state as a different high-arousal emotion is much easier. Brooks called this arousal congruency.
Two limits are worth knowing. The participants were members of the public and students, not athletes. And the per-study sample sizes couldn't be checked against the full paper for this guide, so they aren't reported here.
Jamieson and colleagues 2010
A smaller study by Jamieson, Mendes, Blackstock and Schmader, in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology (2010), tested reappraisal before a real high-stakes exam, the US Graduate Record Examination (GRE).
- 60 students (31 men, 29 women) planning to take the GRE were recruited for a practice test.
- Half were told that arousal improves performance; the control group got no such message.
- On the practice maths section, the reappraisal group scored an average of about 739 against 684 for controls. Verbal scores didn't differ.
- Saliva tests showed the reappraisal group's sympathetic activity rose, not fell. The message didn't calm them down; it changed how they used the arousal.
- One to three months later, those who returned with their real GRE scores showed the same pattern on the maths section.
The catch is the size: only 28 of the 60 took the GRE in time and returned for follow-up, and the main analyses were based on those 28. That's a small sample for a striking result.
What the meta-analyses show
Single studies with striking results often shrink when the full literature is pooled. That's what happened here.
Bosshard and Gomez 2024
A 2024 meta-analysis by Bosshard and Gomez in Scientific Reports pooled randomised trials of stress arousal reappraisal and related "stress can be enhancing" mindset interventions.
- 35 studies, 44 effect sizes and 5,638 participants, 65.1% female, with a mean age of 22.6 years. None involved clinical populations.
- The overall effect on task performance was small: d = 0.23.
- Reappraisal-only interventions gave d = 0.22. Combined interventions with extra content gave d = 0.45, though only five studies tested them.
- Public performance tasks, such as speeches, negotiations, a golf putting task and a dart-throwing task, showed d = 0.34, against d = 0.20 for written cognitive tasks.
- There were signs of publication bias. Smaller studies tended to report bigger effects. After the trim-and-fill correction, the pooled effect fell to d = 0.14, though it remained statistically significant.
- The prediction interval ran from -0.18 to 0.65, meaning a future study might find anything from a small harm to a moderate benefit.
The authors concluded that these interventions are "not silver bullets" but a promising low-cost approach, and they noted it's unclear whether effects transfer between domains, for example from academic tasks to sport.
Inference: d = 0.14 to 0.23 is small. For a triathlete, a small benefit to how you handle the start might be worth having because the technique costs nothing, but it won't transform a race.
Challenge and threat states
Reappraisal sits within a broader framework called challenge and threat. In a challenge state, you judge that your resources match or exceed the demands of the situation. In a threat state, the demands feel bigger than your resources.
A 2025 meta-analysis by Hase and colleagues in the EXCLI Journal pooled 62 studies with 7,418 participants published between 2017 and 2024, across education, sport and other domains. People in a challenge state performed better than those in a threat state, but the effects were small. The risk of bias was generally low, and the authors found only limited evidence of publication bias.
Does anxiety actually hurt sport performance?
This is the question underneath it all. If race nerves don't harm performance, there's less to fix.
A 2026 meta-analysis by Lochbaum and Arendt in Sports pooled studies that measured pre-competition anxiety and self-confidence with the Competitive State Anxiety Inventory (CSAI-2 and its revised version) and linked them to objective performance. It included 48 studies with 3,659 athletes, mostly in individual sports such as golf, martial arts, gymnastics, tennis and swimming, with 24 male-only samples. One sample was 416 Ironman triathletes.
- Comparing better and worse performers, better performers had lower cognitive anxiety (g = -0.52), lower somatic anxiety (g = -0.37) and higher self-confidence (g = 0.59).
- In correlation studies, the links were smaller: cognitive anxiety r = -0.18, somatic anxiety r = -0.24 and self-confidence r = 0.26.
- The prediction intervals for every measure crossed zero, so in a new group of athletes the relationship could be absent or even reversed.
- For raw race times, the correlation between cognitive anxiety and performance was r = -0.00 across 4 samples and 593 athletes. When times were adjusted to each athlete's own level, it was r = -0.30 across 3 samples and 149 athletes.
The authors recommended measuring anxiety on the day, repeatedly and individually, because athletes differ in their ideal zone and in how they interpret their nerves. Inference: for endurance racing, there's no strong case that feeling nervous costs you time on its own. Confidence and interpretation seem to matter at least as much.
The one endurance study
The closest test in endurance exercise is a 2019 paper by Arthur, Wilson, Moore, Wylie and Vine in Psychology of Sport and Exercise.
- In the first study, a cardiovascular pattern more typical of a challenge state predicted lower perceived exertion during moderate-intensity cycling, but not during severe-intensity cycling.
- In the second study, participants were put into a challenge, threat or neutral state before a 16.1 km cycling time trial. The challenge group produced more power, which the authors linked to lower perceptions of fatigue, but there was no significant difference in completion time.
The sample sizes and sex split weren't available in the parts of the paper that could be checked for this guide. It's a single lab study in cyclists, so treat it as a hint that appraisals affect effort perception, not proof that they change race results.
What position statements say
The 2026 ESSA position statement on performance under pressure, by Schweickle and colleagues in Sports Medicine, is a useful summary. It notes that performance anxiety doesn't always mean poor performance, and that athletes can interpret anxiety as helpful, particularly when they feel in control and confident. On relaxation, the evidence it summarises is mixed: in one review, 13 of 21 randomised trials found a positive effect of relaxation on acute performance. Deep breathing as part of a pre-performance routine improved performance under pressure in one experiment with 60 participants.
Inference: calming techniques aren't wrong. They just aren't the only option, and they may be harder to use when arousal is already high.
Using reappraisal on race day
These steps combine the studies above with common practice. They're inference for triathletes, not a tested protocol:
- Expect the nerves. Tell yourself in race week that a racing heart, butterflies and extra toilet trips are normal and will probably happen. Surprise makes them feel more threatening.
- Pick a short phrase. "I'm excited", "this is my body getting ready" or "nerves mean it matters". Brooks's manipulation was a few words said out loud.
- Practise it before it matters. Use the phrase before hard sessions, a test set or a training race, so it's familiar on the day. TriForward's "Self-Talk That Works: What to Say to Yourself When It Gets Hard" covers building cues.
- Pair it with a confidence reminder. Self-confidence was the most consistent correlate of good performance. List three pieces of evidence that you're ready, such as a long ride completed or a strong brick.
- Keep a calming tool for genuine overload. If you're shaking so much you can't put your wetsuit on, or you feel panicky, a few slow breaths are sensible. Reappraisal and calming aren't mutually exclusive.
- Reset after the start. Once you're moving, attention shifts to pacing and technique. TriForward's "Where to Put Your Attention: Internal vs External Focus in a Long Race" covers what to focus on next.
A triathlon scenario
The following example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 36-year-old triathlete is doing her first standard-distance race. In previous sprint races she spent the start pen trying to calm down, felt worse when she couldn't, and went out far too hard in the swim.
This time she prepares differently:
- In race week, she reminds herself that butterflies are normal and expected.
- Before two key sessions, she practises saying "I'm excited, my body's getting ready" when she notices her heart rate rising.
- On race morning, she writes three reasons she's ready on her hand-written plan: a 70-minute brick, her best swim test, and three open-water sessions.
- In the start pen, her heart is still pounding. She says her phrase, then focuses on the first buoy and a steady first 200 m.
Her nerves don't disappear. What changes is that she stops treating them as a problem to solve before the start, which frees attention for her pacing plan. Inference: that's the realistic effect of reappraisal, a small shift in how arousal is used rather than an elimination of it.
Common mistakes
- Treating nerves as a sign you're not ready. Experienced athletes feel them too.
- Fighting a high-arousal state with "calm down" alone. It may be harder to shift than to relabel.
- Expecting a big effect. The pooled benefit is small, especially after correcting for bias.
- Trying it for the first time on race day. Practise the phrase in training, as you would any race skill.
- Using reappraisal to override symptoms that aren't nerves. Chest pain or fainting need assessment.
- Ignoring confidence. Preparation you can point to is one of the more consistent correlates of good performance.
What we don't know
- Whether reappraisal improves endurance race performance. No trial has tested it in triathletes or in real endurance races.
- How big the effect is in athletes. The meta-analysis was dominated by students in academic and social tasks, with a mean age of 22.6.
- How long it lasts. Most studies measured short-term effects over minutes or hours, not a race lasting several hours.
- Who benefits most. Age, population and expertise couldn't be tested as moderators in the main meta-analysis, and no study looked at experienced endurance athletes.
- Whether it helps in the swim specifically, where panic carries a safety risk as well as a performance cost.
References
- Brooks AW. Get excited: reappraising pre-performance anxiety as excitement. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 2014;143(3):1144–1158. doi:10.1037/a0035325
- Jamieson JP, Mendes WB, Blackstock E, Schmader T. Turning the knots in your stomach into bows: reappraising arousal improves performance on the GRE. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2010;46(1):208–212. doi:10.1016/j.jesp.2009.08.015
- Bosshard M, Gomez P. Effectiveness of stress arousal reappraisal and stress-is-enhancing mindset interventions on task performance outcomes: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Scientific Reports, 2024;14(1):7923. doi:10.1038/s41598-024-58408-w
- Hase A, Nietschke M, Kłoskowski M, Szymański K, Moore L, Jamieson JP, Behnke M. The effects of challenge and threat states on performance outcomes: an updated review and meta-analysis of recent findings. EXCLI Journal, 2025;24:151–176. doi:10.17179/excli2024-7995
- Lochbaum M, Arendt F. A meta-analysis of the CSAI-2 and CSAI-2R with objective sport performance from 1985–2026. Sports, 2026;14(8):334. doi:10.3390/sports14080334
- Arthur TG, Wilson MR, Moore LJ, Wylie LJ, Vine SJ. Examining the effect of challenge and threat states on endurance exercise capabilities. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 2019;44:51–59. doi:10.1016/j.psychsport.2019.04.017
- Schweickle MJ, Appaneal RN, Jackman PC, Minahan CL, Moyle GM, Pickering C, et al. Performance under pressure in sport: a position statement from Exercise and Sports Science Australia (ESSA). Sports Medicine, 2026;56(8):1851–1867. doi:10.1007/s40279-026-02472-x
Frequently asked questions
Should I try to calm down before a race?
Not necessarily. In lab studies, people who said "I am excited" before a stressful task did better than those who tried to calm down, possibly because it's easier to relabel a racing heart than to slow it. Gentle breathing still has a place if your arousal is genuinely too high.
Does reframing anxiety as excitement really work?
On average, a little. A 2024 meta-analysis of 35 studies and 5,638 people found a small benefit (d = 0.23), which shrank to 0.14 after correcting for likely publication bias. Almost all the studies were in students doing exams, speeches or similar tasks, not endurance races.
Is pre-race anxiety bad for performance?
Not reliably. Across 48 sport studies, better performers reported somewhat lower anxiety and higher confidence, but results varied widely, and in race-time studies the link between worry and finishing time was close to zero. How you interpret nerves and how confident you feel seem to matter more than their size.
What can I say to myself on the start line?
Something short that labels the feeling as useful: "I'm excited", "this is my body getting ready" or "nerves mean it matters". Practise it before key sessions and training races so it's familiar on race day.
The evidence behind this guide
1 graded principle, 7 sources. Open one to see the sources.
Reappraising pre-performance arousal as excitement or readiness gives a small average performance benefit in lab tasks, but its effect on endurance racing is untestedLimited evidence7 sources
In practice: Expect and normalise pre-race arousal, relabel it with a short phrase practised in training, pair it with evidence of readiness to support confidence, and keep slow breathing for genuine overload. Expect a small effect at most; this is extrapolated from students and short tasks, and never applies to cardiac or panic symptoms.
Most people believed calming down was the best way to cope with pre-performance anxiety. Across experiments, reappraising anxiety as excitement (saying 'I am excited' or reading 'get excited') rather than trying to calm down raised felt excitement, promoted an opportunity rather than threat mindset, and improved singing, speech and maths performance. Non-athlete samples; per-study sizes not checked against full text.
Students told that arousal improves performance scored higher on practice GRE maths than controls (738.57 vs 683.57, d = 0.82), with no verbal difference, and showed a rise in salivary alpha-amylase (sympathetic activity). On the real GRE one to three months later, the reappraisal group again scored higher on maths. Main analyses based on the 28 who returned.
Pooled effect on task performance d = 0.23 (95% CI 0.14-0.33); reappraisal-only d = 0.22, combined interventions d = 0.45 (k = 5); public performance tasks d = 0.34 vs written cognitive tasks d = 0.20. Funnel asymmetry; trim-and-fill reduced the effect to d = 0.14; prediction interval -0.18 to 0.65. No endurance tasks; transfer to sport unclear.
Challenge states (resources judged to meet demands) were associated with better performance than threat states across domains; all pooled effects were small. Risk of bias generally low; only two of five publication-bias methods suggested bias.
Better performers had lower cognitive (g = -0.52) and somatic anxiety (g = -0.37) and higher self-confidence (g = 0.59); correlations were smaller (r = -0.18, -0.24, 0.26). All prediction intervals crossed zero. For raw race times, cognitive anxiety r = -0.00 (4 samples, 593 athletes); race time adjusted to the individual r = -0.30 (3 samples, 149). Recommends day-of, repeated, individual measurement.
Study 1: challenge-type cardiovascular reactivity predicted lower perceived exertion in moderate but not severe-intensity cycling. Study 2: after a challenge, threat or neutral manipulation, the challenge group produced more power in a 16.1 km time trial with tempered fatigue perceptions, but completion time did not differ significantly. Abstract read via search-engine extracts only.
Position statement synthesising reviews on performing under pressure. Pressure training had a moderate effect (meta-analysis of 14 studies, 10 in sport); pre-performance routines moderate-to-large effects (33 studies), best suited to self-paced closed skills; imagery moderate effect, larger with more sessions; notes that performance anxiety can be interpreted facilitatively (challenge states) when perceived control and self-efficacy are high. Classes psychological skills training as control-focused and mindfulness as acceptance-focused, advising alignment when combined.
Get The Forward
Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.
