Softer running-shoe midsoles show a small or uncertain injury benefit in randomised trials, and heavily cushioned shoes don't necessarily reduce impact
Interpretation
Two randomised trials in recreational runners disagree: no difference between soft and hard midsoles in 247 runners (HR 0.92; Theisen 2014), but higher injury risk in a hard shoe in 848 runners (SHR 1.52), confined to lighter runners (SHR 1.80) with no significant effect in heavier runners (Malisoux 2020). Pooled in a Cochrane review (1,095 runners), soft vs hard midsole showed little or no difference (RR 0.82, 0.61-1.10; low certainty), and most shoe-type comparisons showed no injury reduction (Relph 2022). A drop trial in 553 runners found no overall effect but opposite effects in occasional and regular runners (Malisoux 2016). Lab studies in 12 men and 27 runners found maximalist shoes raised impact peak or loading rate by about 11-12% at faster speeds or downhill (Kulmala 2018; Chan 2018), and a review found impact and pronation are not established injury predictors (Nigg 2015). Graded mixed: trial results conflict, certainty is low, and the mechanism (more foam, less impact) is not supported by the lab data. No trial in triathletes or running off the bike.
Practical implication
Don't rely on extra cushioning to prevent injury or choose it by body weight; pick a comfortable level, avoid abrupt switches in cushioning or drop, introduce a new shoe on shorter runs, and focus on training load and previous-injury management. Transfer to triathletes running off the bike is inference, and persistent or bony pain needs a clinician.
Sources
7 sources, independently verified.
Soft versus hard midsole (hard version 15% stiffer at the heel) made no difference to running-related injury risk (HR 0.92, 95% CI 0.57-1.48) or to injury location, type or severity. Higher BMI, previous injury and higher session intensity were risk factors; previous regular running and more weekly time in other sports were protective. Recreational runners, not triathletes.
Two prototypes differing only in cushioning (global stiffness 61.3 vs 94.9 N/mm). Runners in the hard shoes had a higher injury risk overall (SHR 1.52, 95% CI 1.07-2.16); body mass itself was not associated with injury (SHR 1.00). Stratified at the sex-specific median body mass, lighter runners had a higher injury risk in hard shoes (SHR 1.80, 95% CI 1.09-2.98) while heavier runners did not (SHR 1.23, 95% CI 0.75-2.03). The protective effect of more cushioning was seen only in lighter runners, contrary to the belief that heavier runners need more cushioning. Single trial; subgroup finding needs replication.
Shoes with 10, 6 or 0 mm heel-to-toe drop: no overall difference in injury risk (6 mm HR 1.30; 0 mm HR 1.17 vs 10 mm). Low-drop shoes were associated with lower risk in occasional runners (HR 0.48, 95% CI 0.23-0.98) and higher risk in regular runners (HR 1.67, 95% CI 1.07-2.62). Subgroup findings.
Most evidence showed no reduction in lower-limb running injuries when comparing shoe types, at very low to low certainty. Soft vs hard midsole (2 trials, 1,095 runners): RR 0.82 (95% CI 0.61-1.10), little or no difference. Neutral/cushioned vs minimalist (5 trials, 766): RR 0.77 (0.59-1.01). Motion control vs neutral (2 trials, 421): RR 0.92 (0.30-2.81), very low certainty. Shoes prescribed by static foot posture (3 military trials, 7,203): rate ratio 1.03 (0.94-1.13), probably little or no difference (moderate certainty), consistent in men and women; military populations may not reflect recreational runners.
Compared with a conventional shoe, a highly cushioned maximalist shoe increased impact peak by 10.7% and loading rate by 12.3% at 14.5 km/h, and impact peak by 6.4% at 10 km/h, attributed to a stiffer leg at landing. Lab study, men only, no injury outcome.
On an instrumented treadmill, maximalist shoes produced a 12% greater instantaneous loading rate than traditional shoes in 10% downhill running (d = 0.44), with no difference in loading rates on the level. Lab study, no injury outcome.
Review concluding that evidence linking impact characteristics and ankle pronation to running injury risk is not conclusive, and that running injury rates show no clear secular trend despite shoe development. Proposes two paradigms: runners stay in a 'preferred movement path' and select footwear through a 'comfort filter', which may reduce injury risk. Hypothesis-generating; the paradigms themselves are not trial-tested.