Run ·

More Cushion, Fewer Injuries? What Running Shoe Cushioning Trials Show

Randomised trials of soft versus firm midsoles in more than 1,000 recreational runners give a mixed answer, a Cochrane review finds little clear difference, and lab studies show very soft shoes can raise impact forces rather than cut them.

More Cushion, Fewer Injuries? What Running Shoe Cushioning Trials Show

Sprint Summary

The short version — read this if you're short on time.

More cushioning sounds like it should mean fewer injuries, but the trials don't show that clearly. In a double-blind trial of 247 recreational runners, a soft or hard midsole made no difference to injury risk. A larger trial of 848 runners found a higher injury risk in a firmer shoe, but only among the lighter half of the runners, the opposite of the common advice that heavier runners need more cushioning. A Cochrane review that pooled both trials judged the difference between soft and hard midsoles to be small or absent, with low certainty. Lab studies add a twist: very soft maximalist shoes raised some impact forces by about 11 to 12% at faster speeds or downhill, because runners stiffened their legs.

For a triathlete, that means no amount of foam is a proven injury shield, and cushioning is better chosen for comfort than by body weight or marketing. Avoid sudden switches between very different shoes, build into a new type gradually, and manage training load, which matters more for injury than midsole firmness. Pain that persists or sits on one spot on a bone needs a clinician, not a softer shoe.

Safety & Context

Pain that persists, gets worse during a run, changes how you run, or is sharp and localised to one spot on a bone (shin, foot, hip) needs a clinician's assessment, not a new pair of shoes. TriForward's "Bone Stress Injuries in Triathletes: The Warning Signs Before It Becomes a Fracture" covers the warning signs.

If you change to a very different shoe (much softer, much firmer, or a big change in heel-to-toe drop), build up gradually and use the new pair for shorter runs first. A trial found low-drop shoes were linked to higher injury risk in regular runners.

These trials were in recreational runners followed for five to six months and defined injury in different ways. None studied triathletes running off the bike, and none can tell you which shoe will suit your individual body or injury history. A physiotherapist or sports medicine clinician is the right person for footwear questions linked to a current or recurring injury.

This article reports body-mass groupings only as the trial used them. It gives no weight targets and doesn't suggest changing body weight to suit a shoe.

Full Distance

The complete research and analysis.

Walk into a running shop and cushioning is the first thing you'll be asked about. Shoes come in categories from firm and responsive to "max cushion", and a common rule of thumb is that heavier or older runners, or anyone worried about injury, should go softer. For triathletes running on tired legs off the bike, a plush shoe can feel like the obvious choice.

The idea is intuitive: running involves thousands of landings, more foam absorbs more shock, less shock means fewer injuries. But each step in that chain is an assumption. This guide looks at what randomised trials of shoe cushioning actually found, what lab studies say about impact forces in very soft shoes, and how to use that when you choose your next pair.

TriForward's "One Pair or Three? Shoe Rotation, Shoe Mileage and Injury Risk" covers rotation and when shoes wear out, and "Do Carbon-Plated 'Super Shoes' Actually Make Age-Group Triathletes Faster" covers racing shoes. This piece is about cushioning in everyday training shoes.

Where the cushioning idea came from

From the 1970s on, running shoe design focused on two things: softening the impact at landing and controlling how much the foot rolls inward (pronation). Both rested on the belief that high impact forces and excessive pronation cause running injuries.

A 2015 review by Nigg and colleagues in the British Journal of Sports Medicine revisited that belief. The authors concluded that the evidence linking impact characteristics and ankle pronation to running injury risk was not conclusive, despite decades of research. They also noted that running injury rates don't seem to have fallen over decades of shoe development. They proposed two alternative ideas, a "preferred movement path" and a "comfort filter", which are covered in TriForward's "Choosing a Running Shoe: Comfort, Pronation and What the Evidence Supports".

So the starting point is a weaker theory than the marketing suggests. The best way to test it is to give runners shoes that differ only in cushioning and see who gets injured.

The randomised trials

One research group has run the key trials. They gave recreational runners shoes that looked identical but differed in one property, and followed them for months while they ran as normal.

Soft versus hard midsoles: 247 runners (2014)

Theisen and colleagues, in a 2014 paper in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, ran a double-blind randomised trial in 247 leisure-time runners. Neither the runners nor the researchers knew who had which shoe.

  • Design: standard cushioned running shoes with either a soft or a hard midsole. The hard version was 15% stiffer in the heel.
  • Follow-up: five months, with injuries logged online. An injury was any first-time pain from running that stopped normal running for at least a day.
  • Result: shoe type was not associated with injury risk (hazard ratio 0.92, 95% CI 0.57 to 1.48), and there were no differences in injury location, type or severity.
  • What did matter: higher body mass index, previous injury and higher average session intensity were associated with more injury; previous regular running and more weekly time in other sports were associated with less.

The sex split isn't given in the abstract. The last finding is interesting for triathletes: time spent in other sports was protective. Inference: that's at least consistent with swimming and cycling not adding to running injury risk, but the trial wasn't designed to test it.

Cushioning and body mass: 848 runners (2020)

The same group ran a larger trial, reported by Malisoux, Delattre, Urhausen and Theisen in 2020 in The American Journal of Sports Medicine.

  • Who: 848 healthy recreational runners, men and women (the split isn't given in the abstract).
  • Design: two shoe prototypes that differed only in cushioning, with an overall stiffness of 61.3 and 94.9 newtons per millimetre. Inference: that makes the hard version about 55% stiffer (TriForward's arithmetic).
  • Follow-up: six months. An injury was any physical complaint that reduced or stopped running for at least seven days.
  • Overall result: runners in the hard shoes had a higher injury risk (subhazard ratio 1.52, 95% CI 1.07 to 2.16).
  • Body mass on its own wasn't associated with injury risk.

The researchers then split runners at the median body mass for each sex:

  • Lighter runners in the hard shoe had a higher injury risk than lighter runners in the soft shoe (subhazard ratio 1.80, 95% CI 1.09 to 2.98).
  • Heavier runners showed no significant difference between shoes (1.23, 95% CI 0.75 to 2.03).

That's the opposite of the usual advice. The trial was set up partly to test the belief that heavier runners need more shock absorption, and it didn't support it. The authors concluded that the protective effect of greater cushioning was found only in lighter runners.

Two cautions. First, this was one subgroup analysis in one trial, so the lighter-versus-heavier split needs confirming before anyone builds advice around it. Second, "hard" and "soft" here are two specific prototypes, not the full range of shoes on sale.

Heel-to-toe drop: 553 runners (2016)

Cushioning isn't the only property tested. In a 2016 trial in The American Journal of Sports Medicine, Malisoux and colleagues gave 553 leisure-time runners shoes with a heel-to-toe drop of 10 mm, 6 mm or 0 mm, otherwise the same, and followed them for six months.

  • Overall: drop made no difference to injury risk.
  • Occasional runners (less than six months of weekly running in the previous year) had a lower injury risk in low-drop shoes (hazard ratio 0.48).
  • Regular runners had a higher injury risk in low-drop shoes (hazard ratio 1.67).

Inference: the pattern, no overall effect but different effects in different groups, mirrors the cushioning trial. A shoe property can matter for some runners without being better or worse for everyone. For regular runners, the safest reading is that a sudden switch to a very different shoe is the thing to be careful about.

What the Cochrane review concluded

A 2022 Cochrane systematic review by Relph and colleagues pooled randomised and quasi-randomised trials of running shoes for preventing lower-limb injuries in adults. It included 12 trials with 11,240 participants, lasting 6 to 26 weeks.

  • Soft versus hard midsole (the 2014 and 2020 trials above, 1,095 runners): soft midsoles may make little or no difference to the number of runners injured (risk ratio 0.82, 95% CI 0.61 to 1.10; low-certainty evidence).
  • Neutral or cushioned versus minimalist shoes (5 trials, 766 runners): little or no difference (risk ratio 0.77, 95% CI 0.59 to 1.01; low certainty).
  • Overall: most evidence showed no reduction in injuries when comparing different types of running shoe, and the certainty of evidence was very low to low.

Why does the review sound more cautious than the 2020 trial? The review counted the number of runners injured, while the trial analysed time to injury and adjusted for other factors. Pooled with the null 2014 trial, the overall estimate still leans towards softer midsoles but the confidence interval includes no effect. Inference: the honest summary is "possibly a modest benefit from a softer midsole, not proven".

What very soft shoes do to impact

If cushioning absorbs shock, more cushioning should absorb more. Lab studies of maximalist shoes suggest it isn't that simple.

Faster running (2018)

Kulmala and colleagues, in a 2018 paper in Scientific Reports, tested 12 healthy men (average age 27) running in a conventional shoe and a highly cushioned maximalist shoe at 10 and 14.5 km/h.

  • At 14.5 km/h, the maximalist shoe produced a 10.7% higher impact peak and a 12.3% higher loading rate than the conventional shoe.
  • At 10 km/h, the impact peak was slightly higher (6.4%).
  • Why: runners landed with a stiffer leg in the soft shoe, which amplified rather than reduced impact.

Downhill running (2018)

A 2018 study by Chan and colleagues in the European Journal of Sport Science had 27 distance runners run on a treadmill on the level and at a 10% downhill slope in maximalist and traditional shoes.

  • On the level, there was no difference in loading rates.
  • Downhill, the instantaneous loading rate was 12% higher in the maximalist shoe.

These are short lab tests in small groups, the first in men only, and neither measured injuries. Higher impact loading hasn't been proven to cause injury either, as the Nigg review points out. But they show that "more foam" doesn't automatically mean "less impact". The body adjusts to the surface under it.

Why the results are mixed

Pulling it together:

  • The body adapts. Runners change how stiff their legs are depending on the shoe, so the force reaching bones and tendons isn't simply set by the midsole.
  • Injury has many causes. Training load, previous injury and how hard you run were associated with injury in the 2014 trial. Shoe cushioning is one small factor among many.
  • Individuals differ. Both the cushioning and drop trials found effects in subgroups that cancelled out overall.
  • Trials are short and runners aren't triathletes. Five to six months of recreational running is a limited window.

Populations and what's missing for triathletes

  • Recreational runners of both sexes made up the main cushioning trials. Results weren't reported separately for women and men in the abstracts.
  • The lab impact studies were small, one in men only.
  • No trial has tested cushioning in triathletes, or in running off the bike. Inference: tired legs after cycling might change how runners respond to soft or firm shoes, but there's no data either way.
  • Older runners weren't analysed separately.

Practical application

None of this has been tested as a package in triathletes. It's built from the studies above and is inference.

Choosing cushioning

  1. Choose by feel on your normal runs. With no level of cushioning proven to prevent injury, comfort is a reasonable filter. TriForward's "Choosing a Running Shoe" covers the evidence on comfort.
  2. Don't choose by body weight alone. The one trial that tested it didn't find that heavier runners did better in softer shoes.
  3. Don't assume maximum foam means minimum impact, especially for fast running or downhill.

Changing shoes

  1. Change gradually. If your new shoe is very different in cushioning or drop, use it for shorter runs first and build up over a few weeks.
  2. Keep the training plan steady while you switch. Don't combine a new shoe type with a jump in mileage or intensity.
  3. Consider rotating two pairs if you run often. TriForward's "One Pair or Three?" covers the evidence.

Remember the bigger factors

Training load, previous injury and how hard you run were associated with injury risk in the trials, and shoe cushioning had a smaller and less certain effect. TriForward's "Forget the 10% Weekly Rule" covers load and injury.

A triathlon scenario

The following example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 49-year-old age-grouper training for a middle-distance race has had two calf strains in the past year. A friend tells him to "go max cushion" for his long runs off the bike, and he's about to buy a much softer, lower-drop shoe than his current pair.

Using the evidence above:

  • He recognises his biggest risk factor is previous injury, not his shoes.
  • He tries the softer shoe because it feels comfortable, not because he expects it to prevent injury.
  • He notes the drop change. As a regular runner, he introduces the lower-drop shoe on short easy runs over three to four weeks, rather than switching his long brick runs straight away.
  • He keeps his old pair in rotation for long runs while he adapts.
  • He reviews his load. His calf strains both came in weeks where his run volume jumped, so that's where he puts most attention.

Common mistakes

  • Treating cushioning as injury protection. Trials show a small or uncertain effect at best.
  • Buying by body weight. The trial evidence doesn't support "heavier runners need softer shoes".
  • Switching abruptly to a very different shoe, especially a big change in drop.
  • Assuming maximalist means minimal impact. Lab studies found some impact measures rose.
  • Ignoring load. Training errors and previous injury matter more in the trials than midsole firmness.
  • Running through bone pain in the hope a softer shoe will fix it (see the safety notes).

What we don't know

  • Whether cushioning affects injury in triathletes, particularly in running off the bike.
  • Whether the lighter-versus-heavier finding replicates. It comes from one subgroup analysis.
  • Long-term effects. The trials ran for five to six months.
  • How modern high-stack foams compare. The trials used specific prototypes, not today's range of shoes.
  • Whether higher impact loading in maximalist shoes changes injury risk. No trial has tested it.
  • Differences between women and men, which the trial abstracts don't report.

References

  • Theisen D, Malisoux L, Genin J, Delattre N, Seil R, Urhausen A. Influence of midsole hardness of standard cushioned shoes on running-related injury risk. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2014;48(5):371–376. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2013-092613
  • Malisoux L, Delattre N, Urhausen A, Theisen D. Shoe cushioning influences the running injury risk according to body mass: a randomized controlled trial involving 848 recreational runners. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2020;48(2):473–480. doi:10.1177/0363546519892578
  • Malisoux L, Chambon N, Urhausen A, Theisen D. Influence of the heel-to-toe drop of standard cushioned running shoes on injury risk in leisure-time runners: a randomized controlled trial with 6-month follow-up. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2016;44(11):2933–2940. doi:10.1177/0363546516654690
  • Relph N, Greaves H, Armstrong R, Prior TD, Spencer S, Griffiths IB, Dey P, Langley B. Running shoes for preventing lower limb running injuries in adults. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2022;8(8):CD013368. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD013368.pub2
  • Kulmala JP, Kosonen J, Nurminen J, Avela J. Running in highly cushioned shoes increases leg stiffness and amplifies impact loading. Scientific Reports, 2018;8(1):17496. doi:10.1038/s41598-018-35980-6
  • Chan ZYS, Au IPH, Lau FOY, Ching ECK, Zhang JH, Cheung RTH. Does maximalist footwear lower impact loading during level ground and downhill running? European Journal of Sport Science, 2018;18(8):1083–1089. doi:10.1080/17461391.2018.1472298
  • Nigg BM, Baltich J, Hoerzer S, Enders H. Running shoes and running injuries: mythbusting and a proposal for two new paradigms: 'preferred movement path' and 'comfort filter'. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2015;49(20):1290–1294. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2015-095054

Frequently asked questions

Do more cushioned shoes reduce running injuries?

The evidence is mixed. One randomised trial of 247 runners found no difference between soft and hard midsoles. A larger trial of 848 runners found a higher injury risk in the firmer shoe, but only in the lighter half of the group. Pooling the two, a Cochrane review judged the difference small or absent, with low certainty.

Do heavier runners need more cushioning?

That's the common belief, but the trial that tested it found the opposite pattern: the softer shoe was linked to lower injury risk in lighter runners, while heavier runners showed no significant difference between shoes. It's one trial, so it doesn't settle the question, but it doesn't support choosing cushioning by body weight.

Are maximalist shoes better at absorbing impact?

Not necessarily. In two lab studies, highly cushioned shoes raised some impact measures, by about 11 to 12% at faster speeds or downhill, because runners landed with stiffer legs. Whether that changes injury risk hasn't been tested in a trial.

How should I choose cushioning?

Choose a level that feels comfortable on your usual runs, avoid sudden big changes, and introduce a new type gradually. There's no evidence that a specific amount of cushioning prevents injury for everyone. TriForward's "Choosing a Running Shoe: Comfort, Pronation and What the Evidence Supports" covers selection in more detail.

The evidence behind this guide

1 graded principle, 7 sources. Open one to see the sources.

Softer running-shoe midsoles show a small or uncertain injury benefit in randomised trials, and heavily cushioned shoes don't necessarily reduce impactMixed evidence7 sources

In practice: Don't rely on extra cushioning to prevent injury or choose it by body weight; pick a comfortable level, avoid abrupt switches in cushioning or drop, introduce a new shoe on shorter runs, and focus on training load and previous-injury management. Transfer to triathletes running off the bike is inference, and persistent or bony pain needs a clinician.

Peer-reviewed studyRCTIndependently verified
Influence of midsole hardness of standard cushioned shoes on running-related injury risk ↗
Theisen D, Malisoux L, Genin J, Delattre N, Seil R, Urhausen A · 2014 · British Journal of Sports Medicine
247 leisure-time runners (sex split not in abstract), double-blind, 5-month follow-up

Soft versus hard midsole (hard version 15% stiffer at the heel) made no difference to running-related injury risk (HR 0.92, 95% CI 0.57-1.48) or to injury location, type or severity. Higher BMI, previous injury and higher session intensity were risk factors; previous regular running and more weekly time in other sports were protective. Recreational runners, not triathletes.

Peer-reviewed studyRCTVerified — correction applied
Shoe cushioning influences the running injury risk according to body mass: a randomized controlled trial involving 848 recreational runners ↗
Malisoux L, Delattre N, Urhausen A, Theisen D · 2020 · American Journal of Sports Medicine
848 healthy recreational runners (men and women; split not in abstract), randomised, 6-month follow-up

Two prototypes differing only in cushioning (global stiffness 61.3 vs 94.9 N/mm). Runners in the hard shoes had a higher injury risk overall (SHR 1.52, 95% CI 1.07-2.16); body mass itself was not associated with injury (SHR 1.00). Stratified at the sex-specific median body mass, lighter runners had a higher injury risk in hard shoes (SHR 1.80, 95% CI 1.09-2.98) while heavier runners did not (SHR 1.23, 95% CI 0.75-2.03). The protective effect of more cushioning was seen only in lighter runners, contrary to the belief that heavier runners need more cushioning. Single trial; subgroup finding needs replication.

Peer-reviewed studyRCTIndependently verified
Influence of the heel-to-toe drop of standard cushioned running shoes on injury risk in leisure-time runners: a randomized controlled trial with 6-month follow-up ↗
Malisoux L, Chambon N, Urhausen A, Theisen D · 2016 · The American Journal of Sports Medicine
553 leisure-time runners (sex split not in abstract), 6-month follow-up

Shoes with 10, 6 or 0 mm heel-to-toe drop: no overall difference in injury risk (6 mm HR 1.30; 0 mm HR 1.17 vs 10 mm). Low-drop shoes were associated with lower risk in occasional runners (HR 0.48, 95% CI 0.23-0.98) and higher risk in regular runners (HR 1.67, 95% CI 1.07-2.62). Subgroup findings.

Systematic reviewIndependently verified
Running shoes for preventing lower limb running injuries in adults ↗
Relph N, Greaves H, Armstrong R, Prior TD, Spencer S, Griffiths IB, Dey P, Langley B · 2022 · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
12 randomised or quasi-randomised trials, 11,240 adult runners and military recruits, 6-26 weeks

Most evidence showed no reduction in lower-limb running injuries when comparing shoe types, at very low to low certainty. Soft vs hard midsole (2 trials, 1,095 runners): RR 0.82 (95% CI 0.61-1.10), little or no difference. Neutral/cushioned vs minimalist (5 trials, 766): RR 0.77 (0.59-1.01). Motion control vs neutral (2 trials, 421): RR 0.92 (0.30-2.81), very low certainty. Shoes prescribed by static foot posture (3 military trials, 7,203): rate ratio 1.03 (0.94-1.13), probably little or no difference (moderate certainty), consistent in men and women; military populations may not reflect recreational runners.

Peer-reviewed studyCross-sectionalIndependently verified
Running in highly cushioned shoes increases leg stiffness and amplifies impact loading ↗
Kulmala JP, Kosonen J, Nurminen J, Avela J · 2018 · Scientific Reports
12 healthy men, 27 ± 5 y

Compared with a conventional shoe, a highly cushioned maximalist shoe increased impact peak by 10.7% and loading rate by 12.3% at 14.5 km/h, and impact peak by 6.4% at 10 km/h, attributed to a stiffer leg at landing. Lab study, men only, no injury outcome.

Peer-reviewed studyCross-sectionalIndependently verified
Does maximalist footwear lower impact loading during level ground and downhill running? ↗
Chan ZYS, Au IPH, Lau FOY, Ching ECK, Zhang JH, Cheung RTH · 2018 · European Journal of Sport Science
27 distance runners (sex split not in abstract)

On an instrumented treadmill, maximalist shoes produced a 12% greater instantaneous loading rate than traditional shoes in 10% downhill running (d = 0.44), with no difference in loading rates on the level. Lab study, no injury outcome.

Peer-reviewed studyNarrative reviewIndependently verified
Running shoes and running injuries: mythbusting and a proposal for two new paradigms: 'preferred movement path' and 'comfort filter' ↗
Nigg BM, Baltich J, Hoerzer S, Enders H · 2015 · British Journal of Sports Medicine

Review concluding that evidence linking impact characteristics and ankle pronation to running injury risk is not conclusive, and that running injury rates show no clear secular trend despite shoe development. Proposes two paradigms: runners stay in a 'preferred movement path' and select footwear through a 'comfort filter', which may reduce injury risk. Hypothesis-generating; the paradigms themselves are not trial-tested.

Full write-up of this principle

Get The Forward

Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.