Afraid of Open Water: Building Confidence Before Race Season
Fear of open water is common, and it rarely goes away by waiting for race day. What exposure research and cold-water studies suggest about building confidence step by step, with supervision, over weeks before your first race.
Sprint Summary
The short version — read this if you're short on time.
Fear of open water is common, and the evidence suggests it rarely goes away by waiting for race day. The closest research comes from treating phobias: a 2008 meta-analysis of 33 randomised trials found that exposure, meaning repeated, gradual contact with the thing you fear, beat no treatment, placebo and other therapies, and more sessions predicted better results. Cold-water studies add a twist: repeated immersions calm the gasp and fast breathing of cold shock, but in a study of 16 people, staying anxious through the immersions stopped that adaptation happening.
The practical message, which is inference because no trial has tested it in triathletes, is to start weeks before race season, build up one variable at a time, and keep every step calm, short and supervised. Never swim alone, use a tow float and a bright cap, and treat panic as a safety issue: stop, float and signal. Breathlessness, coughing or chest pain that doesn't settle is a reason to get out and get medical help, not something to swim through.
Never swim in open water alone. Build exposure only at supervised venues or with a lifeguard, kayak or experienced swimmer alongside, wear a bright cap and tow float, and know your way out of the water. A tow float helps you be seen and gives you something to hold; it is not a life-saving device.
Panic in the water is a drowning risk, not just an unpleasant feeling. If you feel panic building, stop swimming, roll onto your back or hold your float, and signal for help. In cold water, the first minute of gasping is the most dangerous: enter slowly and don't put your face in until your breathing settles.
Breathlessness, persistent coughing, frothy or blood-tinged sputum or chest tightness during or after a swim can be swimming-induced pulmonary oedema, a medical emergency that can feel like panic. Get out of the water, tell the safety team and get urgent medical help. Chest pain, palpitations, fainting or unusual breathlessness also need medical assessment before you swim again; in a large US case series, most sudden deaths and cardiac arrests in triathlon happened during the swim, mostly in middle-aged and older men.
If fear of water is severe, linked to a past near-drowning or trauma, or spills into daily life, talk to your GP about a referral to a psychologist. The exposure evidence here comes from clinical treatment of phobias and should not replace that care.
Full Distance
The complete research and analysis.
Plenty of triathletes who swim comfortably in a pool feel something very different the first time they wade into a lake. The water is dark, the bottom disappears, the cold takes your breath and there's no wall to grab. Some people adapt within a swim or two. Others find the fear grows the more they think about it, until race day becomes something to dread rather than enjoy.
TriForward's "Open Water Sighting and Race-Start Anxiety" covers the physiology of the race start itself, including how anxiety amplifies cold shock. This guide is about the weeks before that: what to do if open water frightens you, what the evidence on fear and exposure suggests, and how to build confidence without taking risks along the way. It leans heavily on research from outside sport, so the population gaps are flagged throughout.
Why the fear is reasonable
It's worth starting with something that often gets lost in pep talks. Open water is genuinely more hazardous than a pool, and some caution is sensible.
The largest data on this come from a 2017 case series by Harris and colleagues in the Annals of Internal Medicine, which assembled deaths and cardiac arrests in US triathlons from 1985 to 2016:
- 135 sudden deaths, resuscitated cardiac arrests and trauma-related deaths were identified. Victims' mean age was 46.7 years, and 85% were men.
- 90 of the sudden deaths and cardiac arrests happened during the swim, against 7 on the bike, 15 on the run and 8 in post-race recovery. A further 15 trauma deaths happened on the bike. Inference: that puts about three-quarters of the non-trauma events in the swim.
- The overall rate was low: 1.74 per 100,000 participants in USA Triathlon races from 2006 to 2016, based on 4,776,443 participants. It was 2.40 per 100,000 in men and 0.74 in women, and rose to 18.6 per 100,000 in men aged 60 and over.
- At autopsy, 27 of 61 people (44%) had clinically relevant heart abnormalities, most often coronary artery disease or cardiomyopathy.
The authors noted that case finding may be incomplete and that most people's medical history was unknown. The numbers don't tell you that fear causes deaths. They do tell you that the swim is where serious trouble most often happens, and that heart disease nobody knew about plays a part. TriForward's "Winter Open-Water Swimming: Does Cold-Water Habituation Help on Race Day?" covers cold-water risks in more detail.
So the aim of this guide is not to talk you out of being careful. It's to turn vague dread into confidence that rests on real skills: being able to float, breathe, sight, stop and ask for help.
What fear of open water usually is
For most triathletes, open-water fear is a cluster of specific worries rather than one feeling. Common triggers include:
- Not seeing the bottom, or not knowing what's underneath you.
- Cold, and the gasping and fast breathing it causes.
- Losing your bearings, with no lane lines or walls.
- Other swimmers, contact and being swum over at a mass start.
- Feeling trapped, especially in a tight wetsuit.
- A bad past experience, such as swallowing water or panicking in an earlier race.
These are worth separating because they need different practice. Fear of contact is helped by swimming in a group, fear of cold by gradual immersion, fear of the deep by staying close to shore and gradually moving away from it. Writing your own list is the first practical step.
A small number of people have something more severe: a fear that is out of proportion, that started after a near-drowning or trauma, or that affects daily life. That is closer to a clinical phobia, and it deserves professional help rather than a self-guided plan.
The best evidence: exposure in phobia treatment
There are no trials of fear-reduction programmes in triathletes. The nearest well-tested evidence comes from clinical psychology, where exposure-based treatment is the standard approach for specific phobias, such as fear of heights, spiders, flying or water.
A 2008 meta-analysis by Wolitzky-Taylor and colleagues in Clinical Psychology Review pooled 33 randomised treatment studies of specific phobia:
- Exposure-based treatment produced large effects compared with no treatment.
- It outperformed placebo conditions and alternative active therapies.
- In-person contact with the feared situation beat imaginal or virtual exposure immediately after treatment, but the difference had gone at follow-up.
- Placebo treatments were better than nothing, which suggests people with phobias respond somewhat to expectation and support.
- More sessions predicted better outcomes, and multi-session treatments did marginally better than single-session treatments on some measures.
- The type of phobia didn't change the main results.
The participants were people seeking treatment for clinical phobias, not athletes, and the meta-analysis covered many kinds of fear. Inference: the core principle, that fear tends to fall with repeated, structured contact rather than avoidance, is likely to apply to open-water nerves too, but the size of the effect in triathletes is unknown.
How exposure is thought to work
The older idea was that you simply stay in a frightening situation until the fear fades. A 2014 paper by Craske and colleagues in Behaviour Research and Therapy argued for a different model, called inhibitory learning. In this view, the old fear memory doesn't disappear. You learn a new, competing memory, such as "I was in deep water and I was fine", which has to win out over the old one.
The paper gave clinicians practical strategies, including:
- Expectancy violation: designing each exposure so that what you fear doesn't happen, and noticing that.
- Variability: practising in different ways rather than repeating one exact routine.
- Multiple contexts: practising in different places, so the new learning isn't tied to one lake.
- Retrieval cues: reminders that bring the new learning back when you need it.
- Affect labelling: naming the feeling ("this is nerves") rather than fighting it.
- Removing safety signals and safety behaviours that stop people learning the situation is safe.
This is clinical guidance with case examples, not a trial, so treat it as a framework rather than proof. And one strategy needs a firm caveat for open water. In a phobia clinic, "safety behaviours" means things like gripping a rail for reassurance when there's no real danger. In open water, a tow float, a kayaker and a buddy aren't false reassurance. They address real risk, and they should stay. Inference: the useful translation is to drop unnecessary habits, such as only ever swimming within touching distance of a friend's feet, while keeping genuine safety cover in place.
Cold, anxiety and the breath
Much of what people describe as open-water panic starts with breathing. Sudden immersion in cold water triggers the cold shock response: a gasp, fast breathing and a jump in heart rate, strongest in the first minute or so. That loss of control over breathing is frightening in itself, and it feeds anxiety.
Anxiety makes cold shock bigger
In a 2013 study by Barwood and colleagues in the European Journal of Applied Physiology, 11 participants did two 7-minute immersions in 15°C water. Before one, they were falsely told the water was 5°C colder. Peak heart rate was 136.4 beats per minute in the anxious immersion against 124.0 in the control. In a second study of 10 participants, a single anxious immersion after five habituating ones brought the heart-rate response back to its pre-habituation level. Sex split wasn't reported in the abstract.
Repeated anxiety can stop adaptation altogether
A 2017 follow-up by Barwood and colleagues in Physiology and Behavior asked what happens if you stay anxious every time. 16 participants (12 men, 4 women) did seven 7-minute immersions in 15°C water. During immersions two to five, anxiety was deliberately kept high, using deception and a demanding mental arithmetic task. The cold shock response failed to habituate, even in a final immersion where anxiety wasn't manipulated. In earlier studies where anxiety was allowed to fall, it had habituated.
Inference: if every open-water swim is an ordeal, repetition alone may not make the next one easier. Keeping early exposures manageable, short and calm may matter as much as the number of swims.
Practice plus mental skills in inexperienced swimmers
A small 2013 study by Croft and colleagues in Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine tested this in 6 inexperienced swimmers (3 men, 3 women, mean age 22.8). Over a week they did ten 3-minute head-out immersions in 15°C water, with mental skills training to control hyperventilation and improve treading water. Six control swimmers (4 men, 2 women) were immersed in 27°C water instead. In a test in 10°C water, the training group's peak breathing rate on entry fell from 62 to 33 breaths per minute. Inference: that is a fall of nearly half, in a very small sample of young adults.
Do the mental skills add anything?
An earlier study by Barwood and colleagues (2007) in the same journal gave a more cautious answer. 20 men did five free-breathing immersions in 12°C water between two breath-hold tests. Breath-hold time on immersion rose 73% in the habituation-only group and 120% in the group that also had psychological skills training, but the difference between groups wasn't statistically significant.
Taken together, these are small lab studies of cold-water immersion, not swimming races. Habituation through repeated cold exposure is the best-supported part. Psychological skills may help on top, but the evidence for that extra benefit is weak.
Breathing techniques
Slow, controlled breathing is the most common advice for nerves. A 2023 meta-analysis by Fincham and colleagues in Scientific Reports found that breathwork reduced self-reported stress compared with controls across 12 randomised trials with 785 adults (a small-to-medium effect, g = -0.35), with a similar effect on anxiety across 20 trials (g = -0.32). Most studies were at moderate risk of bias, the populations weren't athletes, and the authors warned against hype.
Inference: practising a slow exhale and a calm breathing rhythm on land and in the pool, so that it's familiar before you need it, is low-cost and reasonable. It won't replace gradual exposure, and it isn't a fix for cold shock in the first minute.
Building a graded plan
Here's how these findings might translate into a plan. None of this has been tested in triathletes; it's inference from phobia and cold-water research, combined with standard open-water safety practice.
- Start early. Begin six to ten weeks before your first open-water race, not in race week. The phobia evidence suggests more sessions help.
- List your triggers and rank them. Rate each situation out of 10 for how anxious it makes you, from "standing waist-deep" to "mass start in a crowd".
- Change one thing at a time. Move up the list only when the current step feels manageable. Distance from shore, depth, cold, waves and other swimmers are separate steps.
- Keep early swims short and calm. Ten minutes that end well are better than forty that end in panic. The 2017 cold-water study suggests that staying anxious can stop adaptation.
- Notice what didn't happen. After each swim, note what you feared and what actually happened. This is the expectancy-violation idea in practice.
- Vary the practice. Swim on different days, in different conditions and, where possible, at more than one venue.
- Rehearse the stop. Practise rolling onto your back, floating, holding your tow float and raising an arm, close to shore. Knowing you can stop safely is often the biggest confidence boost of all.
- Practise the skills in the pool too. Sighting, breathing to both sides, swimming without touching the wall and swimming in a busy lane all transfer. TriForward's "Learning to Draft in the Pool: Practising Feet-Swimming Over Winter" covers swimming close to others.
Safety rules that don't change
Confidence-building must never come at the cost of safety. Throughout every stage:
- Never swim alone. Use supervised venues, organised sessions or a boat or kayak cover.
- Be visible. Wear a bright cap and use a tow float.
- Enter cold water slowly and keep your face out until your breathing settles.
- Know how to get out, and agree a signal for help before you start.
- Stop if you're unwell. Swimming with a chest infection or cold raises risk.
- Treat breathing problems seriously. Breathlessness or coughing that doesn't settle with rest is not just nerves.
That last point needs a closer look.
When breathlessness isn't panic
Swimming-induced pulmonary oedema (SIPE) is fluid in the lungs brought on by swimming, often in cold water. It causes breathlessness and coughing that can easily be mistaken for panic.
A 2026 case-control study by Kristiansson and colleagues in Chest compared 258 people diagnosed with SIPE at Sweden's largest mass open-water swim with 2,117 participants without it. Factors independently associated with SIPE were:
- Female sex (odds ratio 5.3).
- Age 61 or over (odds ratio 7.3).
- High blood pressure (1.9) and heart disease (6.0).
- Asthma (1.7), though this didn't hold in a second model.
- Never having swum in open water that season (3.6).
- Previous breathing symptoms in open water (3.5) and a current respiratory infection (10.2).
These are associations from one event, not proof of cause. But two findings matter for this guide. Limited open-water experience in the current season was linked to higher risk, which is another reason to build up gradually before race day. And a respiratory infection was strongly linked, so skip open water when you have a chest infection or cold. If breathlessness doesn't settle when you stop, or you cough up frothy or pink sputum, get out and get medical help.
A scenario
This example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 44-year-old who swims 3 km a week in the pool has entered a standard-distance race in late June. In her one open-water swim last summer she panicked 50 metres from shore and had to be helped out.
In early April she starts at a supervised lake. Her first two visits are ten minutes of walking in, floating on her back with her tow float and swimming parallel to the shore. She practises her stop signal each time. By May she's swimming 20-minute loops with a club group, sighting every few strokes. She then tries a weekday session in choppier conditions and a second venue. In June she joins a club practice start, at the back and to one side.
Fear doesn't disappear. On race morning she's still nervous. But she has done the things she feared, more than once, and she knows exactly what to do if she needs to stop.
Common mistakes
- Waiting until race week for the first open-water swim of the year.
- Doing too much too soon, such as a long cold swim as a first exposure.
- Swimming alone to "get it over with".
- Treating safety equipment as a weakness. A tow float and supervision are sensible, not a sign you're not ready.
- Fighting the fear rather than naming it. Telling yourself "this is just nerves, I know what to do" is closer to what the research suggests than pretending you're calm.
- Ignoring breathing that doesn't settle. Not every breathless moment is panic.
- Racing a mass start before you've practised one. TriForward's "Race Nerves: Why 'I'm Excited' Beats 'Calm Down'" covers race-day nerves more broadly.
What we don't know
- Whether graded exposure works for open-water fear in triathletes. No trial has tested it.
- How many sessions are enough. The phobia evidence suggests more is better, but gives no number for this situation.
- Women's responses. Most cold-water studies here are small and mostly in men.
- Whether psychological skills add to exposure. One small study found no significant extra benefit.
- How well cold-shock studies transfer to wetsuit swimming in racing conditions.
References
- Harris KM, Creswell LL, Haas TS, Thomas T, Tung M, Isaacson E, Garberich RF, Maron BJ. Death and cardiac arrest in U.S. triathlon participants, 1985 to 2016: a case series. Annals of Internal Medicine, 2017;167(8):529–535. doi:10.7326/M17-0847
- Wolitzky-Taylor KB, Horowitz JD, Powers MB, Telch MJ. Psychological approaches in the treatment of specific phobias: a meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review, 2008;28(6):1021–1037. doi:10.1016/j.cpr.2008.02.007
- Craske MG, Treanor M, Conway CC, Zbozinek T, Vervliet B. Maximizing exposure therapy: an inhibitory learning approach. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 2014;58:10–23. doi:10.1016/j.brat.2014.04.006
- Barwood MJ, Corbett J, Green R, Smith T, Tomlin P, Weir-Blankenstein L, Tipton MJ. Acute anxiety increases the magnitude of the cold shock response before and after habituation. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2013;113(3):681–689. doi:10.1007/s00421-012-2473-y
- Barwood MJ, Corbett J, Tipton M, Wagstaff C, Massey H. Habituation of the cold shock response is inhibited by repeated anxiety: implications for safety behaviour on accidental cold water immersions. Physiology and Behavior, 2017;174:10–17. doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2017.02.026
- Croft JL, Button C, Hodge K, Lucas SJE, Barwood MJ, Cotter JD. Responses to sudden cold-water immersion in inexperienced swimmers following training. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine, 2013;84(8):850–855. doi:10.3357/ASEM.3522.2013
- Barwood MJ, Datta AK, Thelwell RC, Tipton MJ. Breath-hold time during cold water immersion: effects of habituation with psychological training. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine, 2007;78(11):1029–1034. doi:10.3357/ASEM.2100.2007
- Fincham GW, Strauss C, Montero-Marin J, Cavanagh K. Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: a meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials. Scientific Reports, 2023;13(1):432. doi:10.1038/s41598-022-27247-y
- Kristiansson L, Seiler C, Braman Eriksson A, Sundh J, Hårdstedt M. Suggested novel risk factors for swimming-induced pulmonary edema: asthma and limited open water swimming experience. Chest, 2026;170(2):477–487. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2026.02.039
Frequently asked questions
Is it normal to be scared of open-water swimming?
Yes. Murky water, cold, waves, no wall to hold and other swimmers are all real reasons for unease, and many confident pool swimmers feel it. Fear is information, not failure, and it usually eases with gradual, supervised practice.
How do you get over a fear of open water?
The best evidence comes from treating phobias: a meta-analysis of 33 randomised trials found exposure-based treatment beat no treatment, placebo and other therapies. For a triathlete that suggests repeated, gradual, supervised swims that slowly build up the challenge. It hasn't been tested in triathletes.
Does practising in cold water help with panic?
Repeated short immersions reduce the gasp and fast breathing of cold shock, but anxiety can undo that. In one study of 16 people, staying anxious across immersions prevented the response from settling at all. Calm, gradual exposure seems to matter as much as the cold itself.
When is breathlessness in open water more than nerves?
If breathlessness, coughing or chest tightness doesn't settle when you stop and rest, or you cough up frothy or pink sputum, it may be swimming-induced pulmonary oedema. Get out, tell the safety team and get medical help. Chest pain is always a reason to stop.
The evidence behind this guide
1 graded principle, 9 sources. Open one to see the sources.
Repeated, gradual exposure is the best-evidenced way to reduce fear, and calm repeated cold immersions blunt cold shock, but neither has been tested for open-water fear in triathletesLimited evidence9 sources
In practice: Start open-water practice weeks before race season, rank your triggers, change one variable at a time, keep early swims short and calm, and always swim supervised with a tow float and bright cap. Treat panic as a safety issue and breathlessness or chest pain that doesn't settle as a medical one. This is inference from phobia treatment and cold-water lab studies, not a tested triathlon programme.
Annals of Internal Medicine 167(8):529-535. 135 sudden deaths, resuscitated cardiac arrests and trauma deaths in US triathlons 1985-2016; mean age 46.7 y, 85% male. Sudden deaths and arrests: 90 in the swim, 7 bike, 15 run, 8 post-race; 15 trauma deaths on the bike. Incidence in USAT races 2006-2016 (4,776,443 participants) 1.74 per 100,000 (men 2.40, women 0.74), 18.6 per 100,000 in men aged 60+; similar across race distances. 27 of 61 autopsies (44%) showed clinically relevant cardiovascular abnormalities, mostly coronary disease or cardiomyopathy. Case finding may be incomplete; pre-race medical history mostly unknown.
33 randomised treatment studies of specific phobia: exposure-based treatment produced large effects vs no treatment and outperformed placebo and alternative therapies; in-person exposure beat imaginal or virtual exposure at post-treatment but not at follow-up; placebo beat no treatment; more sessions predicted better outcomes; effects not moderated by phobia type. Clinical, non-athlete populations; total participants and sex split not given in the abstract.
Clinical guidance paper proposing that exposure works through inhibitory learning rather than fear habituation, with strategies including expectancy violation, deepened extinction, removal of safety signals, variability, retrieval cues, multiple contexts and affect labelling, illustrated with case studies. No new trial data.
Volume 113(3):681–689. Study 1: two 7-minute 15°C immersions, one after falsely being told the water was 5°C colder; anxiety raised peak heart rate (136.4 vs 124.0 beats/min) and ventilation. Study 2: after five habituating immersions, an anxiety immersion produced a heart-rate response no different from the pre-habituation response. Anxiety increases the cold shock response and diminishes habituation.
Physiology and Behavior 174:10-17. 16 participants (12 M, 4 F) completed seven 7-minute immersions in 15°C water; anxiety was raised in immersions 2-5 by deception and a demanding mental arithmetic task. The cold shock response failed to habituate, even in a later control immersion, unlike earlier studies where anxiety was allowed to fall. Small lab study, accidental-immersion context, not swimming.
Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 84(8):850-855. Six inexperienced swimmers had a week of ten 3-minute head-out 15°C immersions plus mental skills training for treading water and hyperventilation control; six controls were immersed at 27°C. In a 10°C test, the intervention group's respiratory frequency on immersion fell from 62 ± 24 to 33 ± 12 breaths/min. Very small sample, young adults, lab setting.
Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 78(11):1029-1034. 20 men matched into habituation-only or habituation plus psychological skills training groups; five free-breathing 12°C immersions between two breath-hold tests. Breath-hold time on immersion rose 14.13 s (73%) with habituation and 26.86 s (120%) with added psychological training; the between-group difference was not significant.
12 RCTs with 785 adults: breathwork lowered self-reported stress vs controls (g = -0.35, 95% CI -0.55 to -0.14; I² 42%); anxiety (k = 20, g = -0.32) and depressive symptoms (k = 18, g = -0.40) showed similar effects. Most studies at moderate risk of bias; authors caution against hype. Non-athlete adults.
Chest 170(2):477-487. Case-control study at Sweden's largest open-water swim (Vansbrosimningen), 2017-2024: 258 SIPE cases vs 2,117 controls. Independently associated with SIPE: female sex (OR 5.3), age 61+ (OR 7.3), hypertension (1.9), heart disease (6.0), asthma (1.7, not significant in a second model) and never swimming in open water in the current season (3.6); in a second model, previous respiratory symptoms in open water (3.5) and acute respiratory infection (10.2). Associations from one mass-participation event, not causal.
Get The Forward
Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.
