Hurting Well: Is Pain Tolerance Trainable?
Endurance athletes tolerate more pain than non-athletes, and in one small trial six weeks of hard intervals raised pain tolerance by 41%. What exercise pain is, how training seems to change it, and why injury pain is a different signal.
Sprint Summary
The short version — read this if you're short on time.
The burning in your legs at the end of a hard effort isn't just a side effect of endurance performance. It seems to be part of what limits it. In a study of 32 recreationally active adults, those who could tolerate more exercise pain rode a 16.1 km time trial faster, and when researchers added muscle pain with a saline injection, 17 healthy men cycled to exhaustion sooner (357.5 versus 430.5 seconds). Athletes tolerate more pain than non-athletes: a meta-analysis of 15 studies found a large difference, and 19 triathletes showed higher pain tolerance and less fear of pain than non-athletes.
Tolerance does seem trainable. In a randomised trial of 20 healthy adults, six weeks of hard intervals raised muscle pain tolerance by 41%, while the same volume of moderate riding didn't. The studies are small and mostly in non-triathletes, but they suggest regular, well-placed hard sessions may build some tolerance for the end of a race. Exercise pain is different from injury pain, though. The burning that fades when you ease off is the kind you can train. Sharp, localised or worsening pain, and any chest pain, are signals to stop.
Training to tolerate exercise pain means the burning, transient muscle discomfort of hard effort, which fades within seconds to minutes of easing off. It never means ignoring sharp, localised, one-sided or worsening pain, bone or joint pain, or pain that changes how you move. Stop and get those assessed. TriForward's "Bone Stress Injuries in Triathletes" covers bone pain warning signs.
Chest pain or pressure, pain spreading to the arm, jaw or back, unusual breathlessness, palpitations, dizziness or fainting during exercise are never something to push through. Stop immediately and seek urgent medical help (999 in the UK).
Don't use painkillers to train or race through pain. Painkillers can mask the warning signs of injury. Talk to a doctor or pharmacist before using any painkiller regularly, and especially before taking one around a long training session or race.
If you have a chronic pain condition, the response to exercise can differ, and hard intervals may not be appropriate. Work with your clinician or physiotherapist.
Full Distance
The complete research and analysis.
Every triathlete knows the last part of a hard effort: the burning legs on the final climb, the last kilometre of a 10 km run that you'd do anything to stop. Some people seem better at staying in that place than others. Is that a personality trait, or something you can build?
The research on this question is small but surprisingly consistent. Pain during exercise seems to limit endurance performance, athletes tolerate more of it than non-athletes, and a few randomised trials suggest that tolerance rises with training, especially hard training. This article covers what exercise pain is, what the studies found, how to use it, and, just as important, where the line sits between pain you can train and pain you should never push through.
Exercise pain is its own thing
A 2024 review by O'Malley, Smith, Mauger and Norbury in Experimental Physiology argued that research often confuses different kinds of pain. It distinguished exercise-induced pain, the transient, non-threatening, acute muscle pain of hard effort, from:
- Delayed-onset muscle soreness, the aching that appears a day or two after unfamiliar exercise. TriForward's "Sore From the Gym, Flat on the Bike" covers it.
- Muscle injury, which involves real tissue damage.
- Chronic pain, which persists for months and behaves differently.
The authors argued that these have different causes and different effects on behaviour, and that treating them as the same can lead to inappropriate recommendations. This is the starting point for the rest of this article. Everything below is about exercise-induced pain: the burning sensation in working muscles that rises with intensity and fades soon after you ease off.
Exercise pain is also different from perceived effort, though the two rise together. Effort is how hard the task feels. Pain is the unpleasant sensation in the muscles. TriForward's "Mental Fatigue" covers how effort perception can change independently.
Does pain limit performance?
Tolerance of exercise pain predicts time trials
A 2017 study by Astokorki and Mauger in the Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports recruited 32 recreationally active adults (23 men, 9 women). They measured pain in three ways:
- A cold pressor test, holding a hand in ice water.
- Pressure pain threshold, with a device pressed into the skin.
- Exercise-induced pain tolerance, measured during a cycling trial at a fixed perceived effort.
They also measured VO2max, peak power and gas-exchange threshold, and then had everyone ride a 16.1 km cycling time trial.
- Neither the cold-water nor the pressure test correlated with time-trial performance.
- Exercise-induced pain tolerance correlated strongly with time-trial performance (R = −0.83). People who tolerated more exercise pain were faster.
- In a regression model, peak power explained most of the variation in performance, and exercise pain tolerance added a further 7.5%.
Two points stand out. First, tolerance of exercise pain seems to matter for performance, on top of fitness. Second, general pain tests like ice water may not capture it.
Adding pain makes you stop sooner
Correlation isn't cause, so a 2021 study by Canestri and colleagues in Psychophysiology tested it directly. 17 healthy men cycled to exhaustion at 80% of peak power after an injection of hypertonic (concentrated) saline into the thigh muscles, which causes muscle pain without fatiguing the muscle, or an injection of normal saline.
- With the painful injection, time to exhaustion fell from 430.5 seconds to 357.5 seconds. Inference: that's about 17% shorter.
- Perceived exertion and pain were higher, and the emotional experience of the exercise was more negative.
- Muscle activity changed, with more co-contraction, and brain activity patterns shifted.
A proof-of-concept study in 17 men is a small evidence base, but it supports the idea that muscle pain is one of the things that makes people stop.
Do athletes tolerate more pain?
A meta-analysis across sports
A 2012 meta-analysis by Tesarz and colleagues in Pain compared athletes with normally active controls in studies of experimentally induced pain. It included 15 studies with 899 participants.
- Pain tolerance, how much pain someone will accept before stopping, was clearly higher in athletes (Hedges' g = 0.87, a large effect, from 12 studies).
- Pain threshold, the point at which something first becomes painful, was also higher, but less consistently. After removing studies at high risk of bias, the threshold difference was no longer significant.
In plain terms, athletes don't seem to feel pain much later than other people. They're more willing to keep going once it hurts.
Triathletes
A 2013 study by Geva and Defrin in Pain compared 19 triathletes, including Ironman athletes, with 17 non-athletes. The abstract doesn't give the sex split.
- Triathletes had higher pain tolerance and gave lower pain ratings.
- They reported less fear of pain.
- Their pain modulation was more efficient, measured by conditioned pain modulation, the body's ability to dampen one pain in the presence of another. Stronger modulation was linked to less fear of pain and lower perceived stress in training and competition.
The authors suggested this may help triathletes keep going during long, painful efforts, and that psychological factors such as fear of pain may play a part.
These comparisons can't show cause and effect. People with naturally high pain tolerance may be more likely to take up and stay in endurance sport. That's where training studies come in.
Can training change it?
Hard intervals versus steady riding
The most important study here is a 2017 randomised trial by O'Leary, Collett, Howells and Morris in the European Journal of Applied Physiology. 20 healthy adults were randomly assigned to six weeks of cycling:
- High-intensity intervals: 6 to 8 repetitions of 5 minutes at an intensity halfway between lactate threshold and VO2max.
- Moderate continuous training: about 60 to 80 minutes at 90% of lactate threshold, matched for total work.
Before and after, they did a tourniquet test of muscle pain tolerance and time-to-exhaustion tests.
- Aerobic fitness improved similarly in both groups.
- Pain tolerance rose 41% with intervals, and didn't change with moderate training (−3%).
- Time to exhaustion at the original intensity rose 148% after intervals, compared with 38% after moderate training.
- Changes in pain tolerance were linked to changes in time to exhaustion (r = 0.44 to 0.51).
The authors concluded that repeated exposure to high-intensity training increases muscle pain tolerance, independently of the fitness gains, and that this may contribute to the improvement in high-intensity exercise tolerance. The abstract doesn't give the sex split.
Moderate-to-vigorous training also helped
A 2014 trial by Jones, Booth, Taylor and Barry in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise assigned 24 healthy participants to six weeks of cycling three times a week for 30 minutes at 75% of VO2 reserve (12 people) or to their usual activity (12 people).
- The training group's aerobic fitness and ischaemic pain tolerance increased.
- Pressure pain threshold and pain ratings didn't change.
- The control group showed no changes.
Inference: this fits the meta-analysis pattern. Training seems to change tolerance more than threshold. It also suggests the intensity doesn't have to be all-out. Thirty minutes at 75% of VO2 reserve is a solid aerobic session, not a sprint workout.
Short-term relief from exercise itself
A separate effect, exercise-induced hypoalgesia, is the short-term drop in pain sensitivity during and after exercise. A 2012 meta-analysis by Naugle, Fillingim and Riley in the Journal of Pain found that aerobic, isometric and resistance exercise all reduced experimental pain in healthy adults. The effect of aerobic exercise was moderate (d = 0.41 for threshold and 0.59 for intensity). In people with chronic pain, the responses were much more variable, and sometimes pain increased.
This is a short-term effect of a single session, not a training adaptation. It's useful mainly as context: exercise changes how pain is processed, and that seems to be part of why trained people respond differently.
Who these studies are about
The evidence comes from:
- Small samples, 17 to 36 people in the experimental studies.
- Mostly recreationally active adults or students, not trained triathletes.
- Men more than women, where reported. The time-trial study included 9 women out of 32, and the saline study only men.
- Lab pain tests: tourniquets, ice water and saline injections, which are not the same as the last hour of an Ironman.
- Short training periods of six weeks.
The triathlete comparison is the one study in triathletes, and it's cross-sectional.
What it means for training
The following suggestions combine the evidence above. They're inference for triathletes, not a tested programme:
- Regular hard sessions may build tolerance, not just fitness. The O'Leary trial suggests intervals did something moderate training didn't. One or two well-placed hard sessions a week, as described in TriForward's "Raising FTP on 8 Hours a Week", may cover this.
- Don't add more pain for its own sake. No study shows that deliberately suffering more than the session requires adds anything. The adaptation seems to come from the training itself.
- Practise race-specific discomfort. The time-trial study found that exercise pain tolerance, not ice-water tolerance, predicted performance. Inference: sustained efforts close to race intensity, late in long sessions, are more relevant than general toughness challenges.
- Work on how you respond to pain. Fear of pain was lower in triathletes and linked to better pain modulation. TriForward's "Self-Talk That Works" covers one of the better-evidenced ways of managing hard moments.
- Pace so the worst arrives late. Pain tolerance is finite. Going out too hard brings the pain forward, when you have the longest to endure it.
- Keep training pain separate from injury pain. Every session where you push through exercise pain should end with the pain fading. If it doesn't, stop.
A triathlon scenario
The following example is illustrative, not drawn from a study. A 42-year-old triathlete training for a 70.3 finds that the last 20 km of every long ride and the second half of every race run fall apart. His training is almost all steady endurance riding and running, with no hard sessions.
A plan based on the evidence above might be:
- Add one interval session a week on the bike, such as 5-minute efforts at a hard but sustainable intensity, building gradually over several weeks.
- Finish some long rides with a block at race intensity in the final 30 minutes, so he practises holding race effort while tired and uncomfortable.
- Use pacing to delay discomfort on race day, starting the bike within his planned power and letting the hard part come in the second half.
- Watch for warning signs. If a knee or Achilles starts to hurt sharply during intervals, he stops the session and gets it checked rather than treating it as part of the pain he's training to tolerate.
Good pain, bad pain
This is the most important section in the article. Training tolerance of exercise pain is useful. Applying it to the wrong kind of pain is dangerous.
Exercise pain you can train:
- A burning or aching sensation spread across the working muscles.
- Rises with intensity and falls quickly when you ease off.
- Symmetrical, affecting both legs or arms similarly.
- Gone, or nearly gone, within minutes of stopping.
Pain to stop for:
- Sharp, localised or one-sided pain.
- Bone or joint pain, or pain that is worse the next day.
- Pain that makes you change how you move, run or pedal.
- Any chest pain or pressure, pain spreading to the arm, jaw or back, unusual breathlessness, palpitations, dizziness or fainting. Stop immediately and seek urgent medical help.
Higher pain tolerance makes it easier to ignore warning signs. Inference: the triathletes who are best at tolerating exercise pain may need to be most deliberate about recognising when pain means something else.
Common mistakes
- Treating all pain as weakness. Exercise pain is normal, but injury pain and chest pain are signals.
- Only training easy and hoping to be tough on race day. The O'Leary trial suggests tolerance comes from hard training.
- Doing every session hard to "build toughness". Hard training needs recovery, and too much can cause injury and fatigue.
- Using painkillers to get through sessions or races. They mask warning signs and carry their own risks.
- Relying on general toughness tests. Ice-water tolerance didn't predict time-trial performance.
What we don't know
- Whether these effects apply to trained triathletes, who already do hard training and may already have high tolerance.
- How long training-induced changes last, or how much hard training is needed to keep them.
- Women's responses, which are underrepresented.
- Long events. The performance tests lasted minutes, not hours.
- Whether psychological training such as self-talk or acceptance strategies changes exercise pain tolerance in triathletes.
References
- O'Malley CA, Smith SA, Mauger AR, Norbury R. Exercise-induced pain within endurance exercise settings: definitions, measurement, mechanisms and potential interventions. Experimental Physiology, 2024;109(9):1446–1460. doi:10.1113/EP091687
- Astokorki AH, Mauger AR. Tolerance of exercise-induced pain at a fixed rating of perceived exertion predicts time trial cycling performance. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports, 2017;27(3):309–317. doi:10.1111/sms.12659
- Canestri R, Franco-Alvarenga PE, Brietzke C, Vinícius Í, Smith SA, Mauger AR, et al. Effects of experimentally induced muscle pain on endurance performance: a proof-of-concept study assessing neurophysiological and perceptual responses. Psychophysiology, 2021;58(6):e13810. doi:10.1111/psyp.13810
- Tesarz J, Schuster AK, Hartmann M, Gerhardt A, Eich W. Pain perception in athletes compared to normally active controls: a systematic review with meta-analysis. Pain, 2012;153(6):1253–1262. doi:10.1016/j.pain.2012.03.005
- Geva N, Defrin R. Enhanced pain modulation among triathletes: a possible explanation for their exceptional capabilities. Pain, 2013;154(11):2317–2323. doi:10.1016/j.pain.2013.06.031
- O'Leary TJ, Collett J, Howells K, Morris MG. High but not moderate-intensity endurance training increases pain tolerance: a randomised trial. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2017;117(11):2201–2210. doi:10.1007/s00421-017-3708-8
- Jones MD, Booth J, Taylor JL, Barry BK. Aerobic training increases pain tolerance in healthy individuals. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2014;46(8):1640–1647. doi:10.1249/MSS.0000000000000273
- Naugle KM, Fillingim RB, Riley JL. A meta-analytic review of the hypoalgesic effects of exercise. Journal of Pain, 2012;13(12):1139–1150. doi:10.1016/j.jpain.2012.09.006
Frequently asked questions
Can you train yourself to tolerate more pain?
There's some evidence you can. In a randomised trial of 20 healthy adults, six weeks of hard cycling intervals raised muscle pain tolerance by 41%, while the same volume of moderate training didn't change it. Another small trial found that six weeks of moderate-to-vigorous cycling raised pain tolerance too.
Do triathletes have a higher pain tolerance?
In one study, 19 triathletes tolerated more pain and reported less fear of pain than 17 non-athletes. A meta-analysis of 15 studies found athletes in general had higher pain tolerance than normally active people. These are comparisons, so they can't show whether training caused the difference.
Does pain tolerance affect race performance?
It seems to. In 32 recreationally active adults, those who tolerated more exercise-induced pain rode a 16.1 km time trial faster. When researchers added muscle pain with a saline injection, 17 men cycled to exhaustion sooner.
How do I tell good pain from bad pain?
The burning of hard effort spreads across working muscles, rises with intensity and fades quickly when you ease off. Sharp, localised, one-sided or worsening pain, bone or joint pain, and any chest pain are warning signs. Stop and get them checked.
The evidence behind this guide
1 graded principle, 8 sources. Open one to see the sources.
Tolerance of exercise-induced pain is higher in endurance athletes, relates to time-trial performance and appears to rise with training, especially high-intensity intervalsLimited evidence8 sources
In practice: Regular, well-placed hard sessions may build tolerance of race discomfort as well as fitness; practise race-intensity effort late in sessions rather than general toughness challenges, and pace so discomfort arrives late. This applies only to transient muscle pain that fades when you ease off, never to sharp, localised or worsening pain or chest pain. Extrapolated from small studies in non-triathletes.
Review distinguishing exercise-induced pain (transient, non-threatening acute muscle pain of effort) from delayed-onset muscle soreness, muscle injury and chronic pain; argues studies often conflate them, which can lead to inappropriate recommendations, and reviews pain models, mechanisms and coping interventions.
Cold pressor and pressure pain threshold did not correlate with 16.1 km cycling time-trial performance, but tolerance of exercise-induced pain did (R = -0.83); in regression, peak power explained most variance (adjusted R2 = 0.739) and exercise pain tolerance added 7.5%.
Hypertonic saline injected into the thigh muscles (pain without fatigue) shortened cycling time to exhaustion at 80% of peak power from 430.5 to 357.5 s versus isotonic saline, with higher RPE and pain, more negative affect, reduced EMG, more co-contraction and altered EEG. Small proof-of-concept, men only.
Athletes had higher pain tolerance than normally active controls (Hedges' g = 0.87, 12 studies); pain threshold also higher (g = 0.69, 9 studies) but no longer significant after excluding high-risk-of-bias studies. Cross-sectional comparisons; cannot show training causes the difference.
Triathletes showed higher pain tolerance, lower pain ratings and lower fear of pain than non-athletes, and greater conditioned pain modulation, which correlated negatively with fear of pain and perceived stress in training and competition. Cross-sectional.
Six weeks of cycling intervals (6-8 x 5 min halfway between lactate threshold and VO2max) vs volume-matched moderate continuous riding: similar aerobic fitness gains, but muscle pain tolerance rose 41% with intervals and not with moderate training (-3%); time to exhaustion at the original intensity rose 148% vs 38%; pain tolerance change correlated with time-to-exhaustion change (r = 0.44-0.51).
Six weeks of cycling three times a week for 30 min at 75% of VO2 reserve increased aerobic fitness and ischaemic pain tolerance; pressure pain threshold and pain ratings unchanged; no changes in controls.
Acute aerobic, isometric and dynamic resistance exercise reduced experimentally induced pain in healthy adults (aerobic d = 0.41 threshold, 0.59 intensity; isometric and resistance effects large); responses in chronic pain were highly variable and sometimes hyperalgesic.
Get The Forward
Research-led triathlon guidance, straight to your inbox. No spam, no filler — unsubscribe any time.
